官官相護?訴訟當事人身分影響稅務訴訟結果之初步證據
Do Judgments on Tax Litigations Show Partiality for the Government as a Litigant? - Preliminary Evidence on Tax Case Adjudicated Decisions
國立臺北商業大學財政稅務系副教授(Associate Professor, Department of Public Finance and Tax Administration, National Taipei University of Business);致理技術學院財務金融系助理教授(Assistant Professor, Department of Finance, Chihlee Institute of Technology);國立臺灣大學會計學系教授(Professor, Department of Accounting, National Taiwan University)
摘要
本研究之實證結果顯示,當最高行政法院在決定是否受理稅務訴訟上訴案件時,若上訴人為稽徵機關,最高行政法院實體審理而不加以程序駁回的機率,顯著高於當上訴人為個人或法人時;而經最高行政法院實體審理後的判決結果,稽徵機關獲得有利判決的機率亦顯著大於個人或法人。這種稽徵機關在稅務訴訟過程中所享有的優勢,即便納稅人延聘了專業的會計師、律師作為訴訟代理人之後仍然存在,惟會計師、律師的確有助於降低納稅人被程序駁回之機率。綜合統計分析之結果,本文無法向民眾提供稅務行政訴訟沒有官官相護之證據。
Abstract
Our empirical results show that relative to the appeals launched by individuals and corporate entities, appeals lodged by the tax authorities have a significantly higher probability of being heard at the Supreme Administrative Court (SAC). Appeals lodged by individuals and corporate entities, on the other hand, are likely to be procedurally dismissed by the SAC. In addition, in the cases adjudicated by the SAC, the tax authorities have a considerably higher chance of winning than do individuals and corporate entities, even when the latter have engaged lawyers or CPAs as their legal representatives. Our univariate and probit analyses consistently indicate that case judgments adjudicated by the SAC demonstrate partiality for the tax authorities, consistent with the assumptions of government advantage theory.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 臺大管理論叢
- ISSN
- 1018-1601
- 卷期
- 25卷1期
- 出版
- 2014年12月
- 頁碼
- 185–214
- 編號
- NTUEJ00010111
同期目錄
- Basu (1997) 盈餘不對稱及時性觀念下,盈餘落後反應對穩健性比較之影響林純央(Chun-Yang Lin);劉啟群(Chi-Chun Liu)・頁 1–32
- 私下募集債券之長期財富移轉效果與經營績效之研究周冠男(Robin K. Chou);陳妙珍(Miaw-Jane Chen)・頁 33–62
- 我國上市櫃公司採行34號公報第二次修訂規定之誘因:以交易目的股票重分類為備供出售為例張嘉文(Chia-Wen Chang);陳明進(Ming-Chin Chen)・頁 63–100
- 發行海外存託憑證可以放寬融資限制嗎?-台灣之實證分析黃志典(Jyh-Dean Hwang);管浥棠(Yi-Tang Kuan)・頁 101–128
- 轉換型領導對工作敬業心的影響歷程:心理資本與服務氣候之跨層次中介觀點陳淑玲(Shu-Ling Chen);黃讌茹(Yen-Ju Huang)・頁 129–156
- 死亡威脅下人生觀對享樂與實用消費之影響謝致慧(Chih-Hui Shieh);凌儀玲(I-Ling Ling)・頁 157–184
- 官官相護?訴訟當事人身分影響稅務訴訟結果之初步證據黃士洲(Shih-Chou Huang);簡銀瑩(Yin-Ying Chien);林世銘(Suming Lin)・頁 185–214
- 面試官與應徵者的性別組合對面談評價之影響:大學教師甄選面談的實證羅新興(Hsin-Hsin Lo);林韶姿(Shao-Tzu Lin);劉佩玲(Pei-Ling Liu)・頁 215–232
- 強制合夥會計師輪調當年度的審計品質分析廖秀梅(Hsiumei Liao);戚務君(Wuchun Chi)・頁 233–258
- 專業經理人職位的代理意涵:台灣電子業家族企業之實證分析李卉馨(Hui-Hsin Lee);詹淑婷(Shu-Ting Chan);蘇怡方(I-Fang Su);鍾喜梅(Hsi-Mei Chung)・頁 259–286
- 當我們同在一起:個人與團隊契合、情感性承諾與知識分享行為之關聯吳欣蓓(Hsin-Pei Wu);陸洛(Luo Lu)・頁 287–324
- 製造服務化發展模式之研究余佩儒(Pei-Ju Yu);陳信宏(Shin-Horng Chen);溫蓓章(Pei-Chang Wen)・頁 325–354