台股外資分析師報告預測目標價之正確性與影響因素分析
Target Price Accuracy in Foreign Analysts’ Reports for Taiwan Stocks
國立交通大學財金所教授(Institute of Finance, National Chiao Tung University);銘傳大學財金系教授(Department of Finance, Ming Chuan University);隆達電子高級管理師(Senior Specialist, Lextar Electronics Corporation)
摘要
本文探究台灣市場外資分析師報告對目標價格預測之可信度,及影響目標價誤差的因
素。文中使用五年共11,446 份報告,觀察不同評估期間下的目標價達成率和目標價高估
與低估的程度。主要發現有四點:一、目標價平均達成率不到五成,發布後三個月內即
達成的比率高於更晚才達成的比例,負向評等的達成率高於正向評等。二、正向評等報
告傾向過度樂觀,目標價誤差大於負向評等。三、外資機構的持股部位與分析師報告建
議相符,傾向持有目標價過度樂觀的股票,這顯示分析師報告具有影響力,且使用者不
易判別報告中的預測誤差。四、目標價格有系統性的高估或低估現象,包括高估中間評
等的大型公司股價、高估分析師報告較少關注的股票、對高市價淨值比股票過度樂觀、
以及對低市價淨值比股票過度悲觀。
Abstract
The study analyzes the accuracy of target price forecasts published by foreign analysts for
listed Taiwan stocks. Using data in 11,446 analysts reports issued over the period of 2006 to
2010, we measure whether target prices are achieved and to what extent the target prices
over- or under-estimate the actual stock prices. For the overall sample, less than 50% of
target prices were achieved by the actual prices within one year, of which, a dominant
proportion was achieved in 3 months after report issuing. Reports with favorable
recommendation have lower percentage of achievement and tend to be over optimistic in
target forecasts. The study finds that foreign institutions held relatively more shares of stocks
that analysts over-forecasted. This suggests that the target prices do affect the portfolio
decision of the buy-side clients, who were unable to tell the systematic bias in the forecasts.
We also find that target price forecasts tend to overvalue large firms receiving modest
recommendations, stocks with fewer analyst reports, high price-to-book ratio stocks, but
under-estimate low price-to-book ratio stocks.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 臺大管理論叢
- ISSN
- 1018-1601
- 卷期
- 24卷1期
- 出版
- 2013年12月
- 頁碼
- 43–70
- 編號
- NTUEJ00010137
同期目錄
- 董監事責任險、債務契約與盈餘保守性許文馨(Audrey Wen-Hsin Hsu);林玟君(Wen-chun Lin)・頁 1–42
- 台股外資分析師報告預測目標價之正確性與影響因素分析謝文良(Wen-Liang G. Hsieh);李進生(Chin-Shen Lee)・頁 43–70
- 專業影評之發行商偏誤及影評方向對消費者影 評接受度之影響:以消費者—發行商認同為干擾因素王仕茹(Shih-Ju Wang);陳明輝(Ming-Huei Chen)・頁 71–100
- 吃硬不吃軟:觸覺資訊對消費者品質預期與折價券使用意圖之影響楊俊明(Chun-Ming Yang)・頁 101–128
- 消費者認知基礎之企業綠品牌形象衡量模式發展張愛華(Aihwa Chang);洪敘峰(Hsu-Feng Hung)・頁 129–154
- 不同型式改良產品之顧客選擇行為張心馨(Shin-Shin Chang)・頁 155–172
- 情緒發洩、報復與利他:服務失誤後之線上負面口碑汪志堅(Chih-Chien Wang);吳宜環(Yi-Huan Wu)・頁 173–206
- 調節焦點對消費者從眾行為影響鄭尹惠(Yin-Hui Cheng);高登第(Danny T. Kao);莊世杰(Shih-Chieh Chuang);陳淑惠(Shu-Hui Chen)・頁 207–232
- 成立專屬保險公司對企業長期績效的影響趙志偉(Chih-Wei Chao);林問一(Wen-Yi Lin);劉亞秋(Y. Angela Liu)・頁 233–256
- 新產品延期上市與競爭者反應強度關係之研究顧萱萱(Hsuan-Hsuan Ku);方儷諭(Li-Yu Fang)・頁 257–284
- 稅法不確定對營利事業短漏報所得之影響:台灣之實證陳俊哲(Chun-Che Chen)・頁 285–320