員工意見表達行為:前因及其對主管績效評量之影響
Employee Opinion Expression Behaviors: Their Antecedents and Influences on Supervisory Performance Evaluation
國立東華大學企業管理學系教授(Department of Business Administration, National Dong Hwa University);國立東華大學企業管理研究所博士候選人(Ph.D. Candidate, Institute of Business Administration, National Dong Hwa University);國立東華大學企業管理研究所碩士(MBA, Institute of Business Administration, National Dong Hwa University)
摘要
管理文獻中常見意見表達方式有建言、異議與犬儒。過去研究並未深入了解不同形式之意見表達行為的性質,與其影響前因和後果的差異。因此,本研究的目的在於探討每種意見表達行為的前因與其對績效評估的影響後果,並且分析員工與主管在意見表達行為上是否具有不同觀點。本研究蒐集配對資料,以281 組中學行政人員與其直屬主管為研究對象。結果發現:(1) 從員工角度來說,自我效能是產生建言和異議行為的重要前因;(2) 從主管角度來說,員工的自我效能與三類意見表達行為均無顯著關係,組織情感承諾才是影響意見表達的重要前因;(3) 就員工角度而言,建言對主管績效評量有正向影響,異議與犬儒行為則無影響;(4) 就主管角度而言,員工不同的意見表達形式會使他們給予員工不同的績效評分:建言對主管績效評量有正向影響,異議則無影響,但犬儒會有負向影響。本研究據此提出理論與實務管理之意涵。
Abstract
In management literature, voice, dissent, and cynicism are the expression forms usually mentioned. Previous studies neither deeply understand the different natures of these opinion expression behaviors, nor discuss the differences of their antecedents and outcomes. Therefore, the objective of this study is to examine the antecedents of opinion expression behaviors, investigate their influences on supervisory performance evaluation, and explore whether subordinates and supervisors have different perspectives on these behaviors. This study analyzes paired data collected from 281 administrative personnel and their direct supervisors in junior high schools. Results show that: (1) from subordinates’ perspective, self-efficacy is an important factor in facilitating voice and dissent behaviors; (2) from supervisors’ perspective, employee self-efficacy is not related to three kinds of opinion expression behaviors, but organizational affective commitment could affect these behaviors; (3) from subordinates’ perspective, voice has a positive effect on supervisory performance evaluation, but dissent and cynicism has no effect; (4) from supervisors’ perspective, various employee opinion expression behaviors result in different appraisals of employee job performance: voice has a positive effect, dissent has no effect, and cynicism has a negative effect. This study discusses the implications of these results for theory and practice.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 臺大管理論叢
- ISSN
- 1018-1601
- 卷期
- 23卷2期
- 出版
- 2013年06月
- 頁碼
- 133–164
- 編號
- NTUEJ00010151
同期目錄
- 購屋者投資機率預測模型之探討邱于修(Yu-Shiou Chiou);周美伶(Mei-Ling Chou);張金鶚(Chin-Oh Chang)・頁 1–28
- 為何台灣的競價拍賣逐漸式微於初次上市市場?江淑貞(Sue-Jane Chiang);吳桂燕(Kuei-Yen Wu)・頁 29–64
- 經理人過度自信對企業發生財務危機之影響:以家族企業特性為調節效果洪榮華(Jung-Hua Hung);王文聖(Wen-Sheng Wang);李易政(I-Cheng Li);陳香如(Hsiang-Ju Chen);張瑋珊(Wei-Shan Chang)・頁 65–96
- 財務會計準則第35 號公報與財務報表公佈時效性范宏書(Hung-Shu Fan);林彥廷(Yan-Ting Lin);陳慶隆(Ching-Lung Chen)・頁 97–132
- 員工意見表達行為:前因及其對主管績效評量之影響熊欣華(Hsin-Hua Hsiung);蔡年泰(Nien-Tai Tsai);陳建安(Jian-An Chen)・頁 133–164
- 工業性產品市場製造商與客戶關係交換模型之研究楊台寧(Tai-Ning Yang)・頁 165–198
- 區位優勢、吸收能耐與創新績效:研發子公司之觀點張元杰(Yuan-Chieh Chang);李亭林(Ting-Lin Lee);簡文強(Wen-Chiang Chieng);秦子閔(Tzu-Min Chin)・頁 199–232
- 多數 / 少數效果對產品判斷的影響:涉入與資訊來源相關性的干擾效果簡怡雯(Yi-Wen Chien);蕭中強(Chung-Chiang Hsiao);邱玉葉(Yu-Yeh Chiu)・頁 233–262
- 運用能力集合擴展規劃產品生產程序蔡榮發(Jung-Fa Tsai);王佩淳(Pei-Chun Wang);蔡宛玲(Wan-Ling Tsai)・頁 263–296
- 部屬親信關係知覺對其行為的影響:正義知覺的中介角色許金田(Chin-Tien Hsu);廖紘億(Hong-Yi Liao);胡秀華(Hsiu-Hua Hu);游謦銘(Ching-Mine Yu)・頁 297–326