台灣股市券商分析師盈餘預測之利益衝突
The Conflicts of Interest on Security Analysts' Earnings Forecasts in Taiwan
中正大學企管所博士候選人(Ph. D. Candidate, Department of Business Administration, National Chung Cheng University);逢甲大學財經法律研究所副教授(Associate Professor, Graduate Institute of Financial and Economic Law, Feng Chia University);中正大學企管系專任教授(Professor, Department of Business Administration, National Chung Cheng University)
摘要
本研究主要探討券商分析師對台灣上市櫃公司發佈的盈餘預測是否會與投資人產生利益衝突。實證結果發現,券商分析師的盈餘預測和自營部門的股票操作有顯著關聯,且無論是樂觀抑或悲觀盈餘預測的股票,所屬券商自營部門均有明顯反向操作的情形,而且有反向操作的股票報酬率是優於沒有反向操作的股票。因此本研究推測券商分析師盈餘預測的利益衝突問題存在。此外,在分析師樂觀盈餘預測下,不論是電子工業類股還是傳統產業類股,均可發現利益衝突,但在分析師悲觀預測下,卻只有電子工業類股才有出現,因而本研究推論利益衝突的產業效應僅發生於分析師的悲觀盈餘預測。
Abstract
This study investigates the possible conflicts of interest of security analysts with market investors when making earnings forecasts. Using a sample of listed companies in Taiwan, we show evidence of close connections between analysts' earnings forecasts and their firm's proprietary dealing department's trading patterns, specifically, our findings indicate that the analyst firm's proprietary trading actions tend to be in the opposite direction as suggested by the earnings forecasts, whether they are optimistic or pessimistic. Additionally, the returns on proprietary dealing department's opposite-direction trading stocks are better than no opposite-direction trading ones. Hence we presume the conflicts of interest exist in analysts' earnings forecasts. Furthermore, we find that the conflicts of interest are presented in stocks of both electronic and traditional companies under the optimistic earnings forecasts, but exist only in electronic companies given pessimistic forecasts, suggesting a possible industry effect of conflicts of interest when earning forecasts’ biases are positive.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 臺大管理論叢
- ISSN
- 1018-1601
- 卷期
- 22卷1期
- 出版
- 2011年12月
- 頁碼
- 357–390
- 編號
- NTUEJ00010199
同期目錄
- 盈餘管理動機與資產減損會計:中國證據曾小青(Xiao-Qing Zeng);李貴富(Kuei-Fu Li);王全三(Chuan-San Wang);黃秋冬(Qiu-Dong Huang)・頁 1–30
- 申購熱潮是長期績效的反指標嗎?王朝仕(Chao-Shi Wang)・頁 31–66
- 超法律制度影響本期股票報酬率:對未來公司盈餘資訊效果之跨國實證研究朱立倫(Eric Li-Luan Chu);吳毓武(Woody Wu)・頁 67–96
- 非營利組織之組織認定歸類模式:利益關係者理論觀點林家五(Chia-Wu Lin);胡宛仙(Wan-Hsien Hu)・頁 97–134
- 主管管理職能提升:自我導向學習與知覺組織支持的交互效果施智婷(Chih-Ting Shih);陳旭耀(Hsu-Yao Chen);黃良志(Liang-Chih Huang)・頁 135–164
- 股權結構與多角化曹壽民(Shou-Min Tsao);金成隆(Chen-Lung Chin);呂學典(Hsueh-Tien Lu)・頁 165–198
- 外部創新多元性、吸收能力,與創新產出:以台灣2000 年到2004 年上市公司為例陳玉麟(Yu-Lin Chen)・頁 199–238
- 工作壓力及其後果的組群差異:以OSI 模式為理論基礎之大樣本分析高旭繁(Shu-Fang Kao);陸洛(Luo Lu)・頁 239–272
- 期望績效回饋效果對企業投資活動的影響:台灣電子製造業之實證研究曾真真(Jen-Jen Tseng);賴勇成(Yung-Cheng Lai)・頁 273–296
- 重大資本支出後的經營績效:成長機會與公司治理的角色黃旭輝(Hsu-Huei Huang);黃一祥(I-Hsiang Huang);張志向(Chih-Hsiang Chang)・頁 297–326
- 會計師意見在財務危機預測之應用與分析蔡璧徽(Bi-Huei Tsai);李正福(Cheng-Few Lee)・頁 327–356
- 台灣股市券商分析師盈餘預測之利益衝突賴紀誠(Chi-Cheng Lai);林問一(Wen-Yi Lin);劉亞秋(Y. Angela Liu)・頁 357–390