條件評估法處理抗議性樣本及無法確定/不知道樣本之一般化架構
A General Framework for Protest and Uncertainty/Don't Know Bidders for Contingent Valuation Method
國立臺灣大學農業經濟學系(Department of Agricultural Economics, National Taiwan University);國立臺灣大學農業經濟學系(Department of Agricultural Economics, National Taiwan University);中華經濟研究院綠色經濟中心(Chung-Hua Institution for Economic Research, The Center for Green Economy)
- 類型
- 論文
- 卷期
- 53期
- 出版
- 2014年12月
- 頁碼
- 1–54
- 編號
- NTUEJ00010621
你目前的連線不在校內範圍,所以無法開啟全文。書目與摘要不受限制;回到校內網路後重新整理本頁,全文就會直接顯示。
摘要
本文主要建立一可處理條件評估法所有誘導支付方式下,產生之抗議性
或無法確定/不知道樣本的一般化架構,所有誘導支付方式可歸納成
「呈現WTP 金額誘導支付」、「純選擇誘導支付」及「選擇加開放誘
導支付」等三大類詢價模式。此一架構除了可以更有效、更簡易的估計
方式處理抗議性樣本外,尚可合併處理抗議性樣本及過去極少涉及的無
法確定/不知道樣本。而此一般化架構將以雙界二元選擇加開放條件評
估法,所調查完成評估墾丁國家公園價值之資料為驗證,墾丁國家公園
的抗議性與無法確定/不知道樣本佔整體樣本約37%,結果顯示本文所
建立的一般化架構,在處理只涵蓋抗議性樣本或是同時處理抗議性及無
法確定/不知道樣本之結果,比過去將抗議性樣本和無法確定/不知道
樣本刪除,或視抗議性樣本為零時更有效。同時也讓過去將抗議性樣本
及無法確定/不知道樣本刪除,估計而來的平均WTP 之高估情形,或
是將抗議性樣本視為零支付處理方式,所產生之平均WTP 之低估情形
得以避免。然結果則一致顯示,不論是傳統將抗議性樣本及無法確定/
不知道樣本刪除,或以不當方式納入抗議性樣本的處理方式,均使得對
應母體總數因而縮減或/及平均WTP 低估,因此傳統處理方式均低估
資源總價值,低估比例最高達142%、最少為31%。
Abstract
The purpose of this study is to construct a general framework to treat the
protest bidders and uncertainty/don’t know responses in contingent valuation
method (CVM). This framework is applicable to all kinds of elicitation
methods in CVM. All types of elicitation methods are classified as three
groups. They are “WTP revelation”, “pure discrete choice,” and “discrete
choice with open question follow-up.” Such framework is much more
efficient and easier estimation in treating protest bidders and/or handling
uncertainty/don’t know responses which are rarely accounted for. The
estimation results from this general framework will be compared with those
traditional treatments. Traditionally, it is normally delete the protest and
uncertainly/don’t know responses or treat the protest bidders with zero
willingness to pay. This framework is applied to the case of benefit
evaluation of Kenting National Park conducted by double-bounded discrete
with open question follow-up elicitation method.
There is 37% of protest and uncertainty/don’t know bidders in this survey.
The results from this general framework show that the treatment of protest
responses only or the treatment of protest and uncertainty/don’t know
responses have relatively high efficiency than those from the traditional
treatments with such high percentage of protest and uncertainty/don’t know
responses for this sample. The estimated average willingness to pay (WTP)
is over estimated while the protests and uncertainty/don’t know responses
are excluded traditionally. On the other hand, the estimated average WTP
is under estimated while the protests are treated as zero WTP responses.
However, total benefit of the National Park is under estimated in either
treatment of protests and/or don’t know bidders. The under estimation is
caused either by the shrink of population due to the elimination of protests or
by zero WTP responses for protesters. The total benefit is under estimated
by 142% as the highest and at least by 31%.