臺大學術期刊資料庫NTU Journal Database

「資源邊界」與「共用資源自主治理」-以蘭嶼飛魚漁場衝突事件為例

Resources Boundaries and Self-Governed CPRs: Using the Conflict of Fisheries Grounds of Flying Fish around The Orchid Island As An Example

林育賜(Yu-Tzu Lin)

國立政治大學外交學系(Department of Diplomacy, National Cheng-Chi University)

類型
論文
卷期
51期
出版
2013年12月
頁碼
87–115
編號
NTUEJ00010631
全文限校內本刊全文只能在臺大校內網路閱讀。

你目前的連線不在校內範圍,所以無法開啟全文。書目與摘要不受限制;回到校內網路後重新整理本頁,全文就會直接顯示。

摘要

漁業資源是典型的「共用資源」(common-pool resources, CPRs),共
用資源的使用者雖知若一同減少使用資源,將獲得最高的集體利
益,但還是會陷入繼續耗用共用資源的困境。自1960 年代以來,學
界普遍是在Hardin (1968) 所提出的方向下來思考如何由國家立法或
價格機制來避免共用資源的耗竭;但1990 年代初Ostrom (1990) 另
闢蹊徑,提出由「資源使用團體來自主治理共用資源」。
本文以蘭嶼飛魚漁場衝突事件為引,闡明蘭嶼附近海域的漁場面臨
了共用資源困境,繼而檢視Ostrom (1990) 的共用資源自主治理理論
以及蘭嶼的傳統漁場分配制度,在以Ostrom (1990) 的「清楚定義的
邊界原則」來檢視此衝突事件後發現,一個原本可解決共用資源困
境的原生性制度會因為使用者邊界被打破而受到影響;再者,政府
為調和此一衝突,另行創設了一條資源使用邊界,來區分原資源使
用者(達悟)與新加入的資源使用者(漢),但卻未考量自然資源
使用的「公眾信託原則」(public trust doctrine)。
此案例亦昭示,由於飛魚跨界洄游產卵,一地或一國的政策是否能
達成飛魚資源之永續,會受到其他沿岸國如何使用洄游到其海域飛
魚的影響,此時對於共用資源的治理就不能僅限於一地之自主治
理,而是要從跨國或跨界的尺度來思維。再者,僅強調原住民族對
傳統海域的自主治理,無法充份解決共用資源困境。因此,思索如
何融合Hardin (1968) 以及Ostrom (1990) 的理論,並依不同尺度來彈
性使用解決方案或為未來要務。

Abstract

Fisheries resources are typical Common-Pool Resources (CPRs); users of
CPRs know that if they used resources less together, they would get the
highest collective benefits. Even so, they would go on exploiting
resources respectively, trapped in such a dilemma. Since 1960s, the social
science community had been thinking about how to solve the tragedy of
over-exploitation under Hardin’s model, a paradigm which resorts to
national legislations or the price mechanism. The paradigm seemed to be
shifted in 1990s: Ostrom proposed the ‘CPR self-governance of User
Groups’ theory as another solution.
This article started with the conflict of fisheries grounds of flying fish
around the Orchid Island, a conflict that the author viewed as the CPRs
dilemma. Then the author reexamined CPR self-governance theory and the
indigenous institution of fisheries grounds around this island. On the basis
of the principle of ‘clearly defined boundary principle’ proposed by Ostrom,
it was found that an enduring self-governance fisheries ground institution
could be impacted by the breaking of resources boundaries. In addition,
solving this conflict, the government intervened with a new resource
boundary which distinguished original and new users. However, the
Public Trust Doctrine was not considered by the government.
This case also showed that a cross-country or cross-boundary scale of CPR
governance should be applied because the flying fish migrated to different
places in different phases of their life cycle. Additionally, this case
reflected that self-governance was not enough for solving the CPR dilemma.
Therefore, it would be an important task in the future to develop such an
approach, which accommodates Hardin’s and Ostrom’s solutions and
applies suitable solutions by different scales of governance.

關鍵詞

程式與 AI 助手可以改用資料介面(JSON、MCP),查詢比讀頁面快。給程式與 AI 代理的存取說明