A Comparative Study on the Protection of Citizens’ Right to Health Focus on the Public Health Policy of Korea and the USA
Hoseo University
- 類型
- 論文
- 卷期
- 14卷2期
- 出版
- 2019年03月
- 頁碼
- 179–226
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000107
需要全文時,可以向出版單位洽詢,聯絡方式見期刊資訊。
摘要
The Constitution of the Republic of Korea adopts the principle
of social state as a constitutional ideology and sets the right to
health as the fundamental right of the people. In order to
implement the citizens’ right to health, Korea has adopted
national health insurance, in particular public methods, in which
the state directly intervenes in the medical market. All Koreans
are compulsorily enrolled in National Health Insurance, and pay
their premiums in proportion to their income to the National
Health Insurance Corporation. All medical institutions are also
enforced in the national health insurance system. Under this
system, anyone who needs medical care can receive universal
basic medical treatment at low cost. National health insurance in
Korea has institutionalized that, at the very least, it should not be
deprived of even the least opportunity to enjoy health because of
economic barriers. In Korea, the universal health insurance
system has been accepted as natural because of the combination
of solidarity and shared responsibility.
On the other hand, the United States (hereinafter “U.S.”), the
world’s most powerful nation, seems to have a different situation
and different views from Korea. It is natural to recognize that differences in economic ability may or may not guarantee
minimum health. Of course there have been attempts by the
Clinton and Obama administrations to ensure universal health,
but they still have not progressed to the same level as social
insurance. Obamacare is to force all citizens to join private health
insurance, penalize them for violations, and provide tax relief for
low-income people. However, this was not free from the
unconstitutional debate. Unlike the Korean Constitution, the U.S.
Constitution does not directly stipulate the right to health. In
addition, the federal state, the U.S. of America, places emphasis
on individual freedom and guarantees state independence and
federalism is an important ideology. Even if the United States
emphasizes individuals or local autonomy rather than the
solidarity of the community, is it impossible to interpret from the
US Constitution the universal health right of the people?
In this paper, through the comparison with Korea, we wanted
and tried to demonstrate that citizens’ health rights can be derived
as universal rights through the interpretation of the U.S.
Constitution, and that Obama Care is a practical example of such
an attempt.
Abstract
The Constitution of the Republic of Korea adopts the principle
of social state as a constitutional ideology and sets the right to
health as the fundamental right of the people. In order to
implement the citizens’ right to health, Korea has adopted
national health insurance, in particular public methods, in which
the state directly intervenes in the medical market. All Koreans
are compulsorily enrolled in National Health Insurance, and pay
their premiums in proportion to their income to the National
Health Insurance Corporation. All medical institutions are also
enforced in the national health insurance system. Under this
system, anyone who needs medical care can receive universal
basic medical treatment at low cost. National health insurance in
Korea has institutionalized that, at the very least, it should not be
deprived of even the least opportunity to enjoy health because of
economic barriers. In Korea, the universal health insurance
system has been accepted as natural because of the combination
of solidarity and shared responsibility.
On the other hand, the United States (hereinafter “U.S.”), the
world’s most powerful nation, seems to have a different situation
and different views from Korea. It is natural to recognize that differences in economic ability may or may not guarantee
minimum health. Of course there have been attempts by the
Clinton and Obama administrations to ensure universal health,
but they still have not progressed to the same level as social
insurance. Obamacare is to force all citizens to join private health
insurance, penalize them for violations, and provide tax relief for
low-income people. However, this was not free from the
unconstitutional debate. Unlike the Korean Constitution, the U.S.
Constitution does not directly stipulate the right to health. In
addition, the federal state, the U.S. of America, places emphasis
on individual freedom and guarantees state independence and
federalism is an important ideology. Even if the United States
emphasizes individuals or local autonomy rather than the
solidarity of the community, is it impossible to interpret from the
US Constitution the universal health right of the people?
In this paper, through the comparison with Korea, we wanted
and tried to demonstrate that citizens’ health rights can be derived
as universal rights through the interpretation of the U.S.
Constitution, and that Obama Care is a practical example of such
an attempt.