A Third Way Forward: The Fate of BITs in the Internal Market and China’s Choice
Lecturer of international economic law at School of Law, Guizhou Minzu University.
摘要
Both the European Union (hereinafter “EU”) and China reject Investor-State Dispute Settlement (hereinafter “ISDS”) mechanisms in their internal market integration, but exhibit a positive stance toward ISDS reform in their external relations with third countries. However, the fate of bilateral investment treaties (hereinafter “BITs”) within China is distinct from that of intra-EU BITs. While most EU Member States terminated their intra-EU BITs, China maintains its BIT-styled Mainland and Macao Closer Economic Partnership Arrangement Investment Agreement and Mainland and Hong Kong Closer Economic Partnership Arrangement Investment Agreement (hereinafter “CEPA Investment Agreements”) which omit the ISDS clauses. While BITs carving out ISDS clauses do have some value in both the EU context and the Chinese context, the divergent path of China can be principally attributed to its unique “one country, two systems” framework, which limits the tools available for integration and allows the continued application of an “international law model” of integration. China’s distinct tradition and emphasis on the rule of law further influence its approach. Nonetheless, the implementation flaws of China’s CEPA Investment Agreements are more obvious when compared to the EU, due to the absence of comparable control mechanisms. Following the enactment of the Foreign Investment Law of the People’s Republic of China (hereinafter “Foreign Investment Law”), the role of the CEPA Investment Agreements in facilitating cross-border investment requires reevaluation. Given the executive-led system of China, investment facilitation could be a suitable approach to protect and promote cross-border investments within the country.
Abstract
Both the European Union (hereinafter “EU”) and China reject Investor-State Dispute Settlement (hereinafter “ISDS”) mechanisms in their internal market integration, but exhibit a positive stance toward ISDS reform in their external relations with third countries. However, the fate of bilateral investment treaties (hereinafter “BITs”) within China is distinct from that of intra-EU BITs. While most EU Member States terminated their intra-EU BITs, China maintains its BIT-styled Mainland and Macao Closer Economic Partnership Arrangement Investment Agreement and Mainland and Hong Kong Closer Economic Partnership Arrangement Investment Agreement (hereinafter “CEPA Investment Agreements”) which omit the ISDS clauses. While BITs carving out ISDS clauses do have some value in both the EU context and the Chinese context, the divergent path of China can be principally attributed to its unique “one country, two systems” framework, which limits the tools available for integration and allows the continued application of an “international law model” of integration. China’s distinct tradition and emphasis on the rule of law further influence its approach. Nonetheless, the implementation flaws of China’s CEPA Investment Agreements are more obvious when compared to the EU, due to the absence of comparable control mechanisms. Following the enactment of the Foreign Investment Law of the People’s Republic of China (hereinafter “Foreign Investment Law”), the role of the CEPA Investment Agreements in facilitating cross-border investment requires reevaluation. Given the executive-led system of China, investment facilitation could be a suitable approach to protect and promote cross-border investments within the country.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- Asian Journal of WTO & International Health Law and policy
- ISSN
- 1819-5164
- 卷期
- 20卷2期
- 出版
- 2025年09月
- 頁碼
- 351–384
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000011
同期目錄
- A Conversation with Robert HudecJose Manuel Alvarez Zárate・頁 249–267
- FTAs and Fragmentation of Trade Remedy Rules—Lessons Drawn from Experiences of VietnamThi Truc Linh Phan & Jaemin Lee・頁 269–313
- Regulating Aberration: Tapping into the Ordinary Course of Trade Test vis-à-vis State-Caused Distortions in CommerceXueji Su・頁 315–350
- A Third Way Forward: The Fate of BITs in the Internal Market and China’s ChoiceHongling Ning・頁 351–384
- Tangled Warfare in a Vicious Circle: A Quantitative Analysis on the WTO Safety Valve Measures and NetworkXia Luo・頁 385–427
- The Precautionary Principle as a General Principle of International Law and Global Health LawThanh Hải Đoàn・頁 429–485
- A Book Review on Chios Carmody "A Communitarian Theory of WTO Law" (Cambridge University Press, 2024)Shin-Yi Peng・頁 487–493