WTO and the Protection of Public Morals Balancing Consumer Welfare and Public Interest in Competition Law
Indian Institute of Management Calcutta
摘要
The World Trade Organization (hereinafter “WTO”) members’ right to adopt measures to achieve certain nontrade objectives, notwithstanding any other provisions of WTO agreements, is well entrenched in the WTO legal system. These objectives, listed as general exceptions, have been a matter of contestation in several WTO disputes. One such exception that has found increased use in recent times is the adoption of measures to protect “public morals”. This paper attempts to analyse the scope and meaning of the public moral exception in the WTO context with specific reference to the evolving jurisprudence of the WTO, and its implication on the practices of WTO member States. The paper shall look at the evolving jurisprudence and the regulatory discretion as interpreted by the WTO panels and the Appellate Body (hereinafter “AB”). The paper finds that the WTO adjudicating bodies have taken a more lenient approach while interpreting the public moral exception and have shown deference to Members’ own determinations rather than imposing their own version of what constitute “public moral” in a given context. The Panel/AB’s show of deference towards national determination and the broadening of the scope of the public morals exception, however, have been balanced by a tightened necessity test. Although, this may have adverse implications on the use/abuse of the general exceptions.
Abstract
The World Trade Organization (hereinafter “WTO”) members’ right to adopt measures to achieve certain nontrade objectives, notwithstanding any other provisions of WTO agreements, is well entrenched in the WTO legal system. These objectives, listed as general exceptions, have been a matter of contestation in several WTO disputes. One such exception that has found increased use in recent times is the adoption of measures to protect “public morals”. This paper attempts to analyse the scope and meaning of the public moral exception in the WTO context with specific reference to the evolving jurisprudence of the WTO, and its implication on the practices of WTO member States. The paper shall look at the evolving jurisprudence and the regulatory discretion as interpreted by the WTO panels and the Appellate Body (hereinafter “AB”). The paper finds that the WTO adjudicating bodies have taken a more lenient approach while interpreting the public moral exception and have shown deference to Members’ own determinations rather than imposing their own version of what constitute “public moral” in a given context. The Panel/AB’s show of deference towards national determination and the broadening of the scope of the public morals exception, however, have been balanced by a tightened necessity test. Although, this may have adverse implications on the use/abuse of the general exceptions.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- Asian Journal of WTO & International Health Law and policy
- ISSN
- 1819-5164
- 卷期
- 13卷2期
- 出版
- 2018年09月
- 頁碼
- 333–354
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000113
同期目錄
- Forward to the Special Issue on “Revisiting ‘Exceptions’ under International Economic Law林彩瑜(Tsai-yu Lin)・頁 275–276
- Commercializing National Security? - National Security Exceptions’ Outer Parameter in GATT Article XXIJaemin Lee・頁 277–310
- Petrificus Totalus: The Spell of National Security!R.V. Anuradha・頁 311–332
- WTO and the Protection of Public Morals Balancing Consumer Welfare and Public Interest in Competition LawR. Rajesh Babu・頁 333–354
- Halal Food, Market Access and Exception to WTO Law: New Aspects Learned from Indonesia-Chicken ProductsHaniff Ahamat;Nasarudin Abdul Rahman・頁 355–373
- Revisiting the Public Moral/Order and the Security Exceptions Under the GATSRolf H. Weber;Rainer Baisch・頁 375–394
- The Evolving Prudential Exceptions in Regional Trade Agreements楊岳平(Yueh-Ping Yang)・頁 395–441
- The Evolving Prudential Exceptions in Regional Trade AgreementMa. Joy V. Abrenica・頁 443–462
- “Soft Law” in International Law-Making - How Soft International Taxation Law Is Reshaping International Economic GovernanceJulien Chaisse;Xueliang Ji・頁 463–509
- What Should China Learn from the CPTPP Environmental Provisions?Haifeng Deng;Jie (Jeanne) Huang・頁 511–550
- Subsidy Extinction and The Distinction Between Company and Shareholders Under the SCM Agreement: Proposing A Control-Centered Approach羅致遠(Chih-yuan Lo)・頁 551–578