Tangled Warfare in a Vicious Circle: A Quantitative Analysis on the WTO Safety Valve Measures and Network
Candidate for Ph.D. in Laws, Faculty of Law, The Chinese University of Hong Kong.
摘要
It is approaching three decades since the establishment of the World Trade Organization (hereinafter “WTO”), whose founding aim, liberalization, has allowed it to successfully change the pattern of trading among its Members, exerting a profound impact on the global economic and political environment. Owing to the creation of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) in 1948 and the inception of its successor, the WTO, in 1995, the world’s merchandise exports and imports have experienced tremendous growth. Even so, during the course of lowering barriers and encouraging trade, this robust system has also provided a “safety valve” mechanism to its Members, so as to protect their national interests against any “unfair” competition or “unforeseen development” accompanying that trade liberalization. This “safety valve” (hereinafter “SV”), consisting of Anti-dumping, Anti-subsidy, and Safeguard measures, entitles Members to legitimately adopt protective remedies against the negative impact of foreign importation. Unfortunately, however, it has also become a problem itself. In particular, empirical evidence documenting the increasing use of “SV” measures (hereinafter “SVM”) has resulted in a growing number of disputes being brought before the Dispute Settlement Body (DSB) of the WTO. Under this circumstance, WTO Members adopted different strategies to impose their own SVMs against the others or to cooperate/counterattack when facing investigations initiated by their counterparties. While academia has devoted decades of attention to this tangled warfare in terms of SVM, previous empirical analyses have primarily focused on a single type of SVM and have been limited to a case-by-case basis, failing to provide an overview of all SVMs from a longitudinal perspective. Furthermore, despite the widespread acknowledgement and application of quantitative research methods by scholars across various disciplines in the past decades, there have been limited quantitative studies in this area, with a few exceptions from purely economic perspectives. In light of these circumstances, this study intended to explore the overall situation of the global SVM application over the past twenty-five years and whether a deeper understanding of the SV mechanism can be obtained from a global/macro level through the application of quantitative approaches. To achieve this, this study initially collected all SVM investigations initiated by the WTO Members from 1995 to 2020, constructing a database that focuses on key components of a typical SVM investigation, such as players, products, duration, etc., so as to obtain a comprehensive understanding on the global application of SV measures from chronological and categorical angles. In addition, this study employed various quantitative research techniques to analyze the database extensively, identifying trends of the global SVM application during 1995-2020, and revealing the interrelationships between imposing members, targeted products, types of SVM, and days of measure in force. Furthermore, an SVM network was established, accompanied by an exploration of key players and essential features within the network. Based on these findings, this study offered perspectives on the related implications and proposed feasible ways to alleviate the current tangled SVM warfare in a vicious circle.
Abstract
It is approaching three decades since the establishment of the World Trade Organization (hereinafter “WTO”), whose founding aim, liberalization, has allowed it to successfully change the pattern of trading among its Members, exerting a profound impact on the global economic and political environment. Owing to the creation of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) in 1948 and the inception of its successor, the WTO, in 1995, the world’s merchandise exports and imports have experienced tremendous growth. Even so, during the course of lowering barriers and encouraging trade, this robust system has also provided a “safety valve” mechanism to its Members, so as to protect their national interests against any “unfair” competition or “unforeseen development” accompanying that trade liberalization. This “safety valve” (hereinafter “SV”), consisting of Anti-dumping, Anti-subsidy, and Safeguard measures, entitles Members to legitimately adopt protective remedies against the negative impact of foreign importation. Unfortunately, however, it has also become a problem itself. In particular, empirical evidence documenting the increasing use of “SV” measures (hereinafter “SVM”) has resulted in a growing number of disputes being brought before the Dispute Settlement Body (DSB) of the WTO. Under this circumstance, WTO Members adopted different strategies to impose their own SVMs against the others or to cooperate/counterattack when facing investigations initiated by their counterparties. While academia has devoted decades of attention to this tangled warfare in terms of SVM, previous empirical analyses have primarily focused on a single type of SVM and have been limited to a case-by-case basis, failing to provide an overview of all SVMs from a longitudinal perspective. Furthermore, despite the widespread acknowledgement and application of quantitative research methods by scholars across various disciplines in the past decades, there have been limited quantitative studies in this area, with a few exceptions from purely economic perspectives. In light of these circumstances, this study intended to explore the overall situation of the global SVM application over the past twenty-five years and whether a deeper understanding of the SV mechanism can be obtained from a global/macro level through the application of quantitative approaches. To achieve this, this study initially collected all SVM investigations initiated by the WTO Members from 1995 to 2020, constructing a database that focuses on key components of a typical SVM investigation, such as players, products, duration, etc., so as to obtain a comprehensive understanding on the global application of SV measures from chronological and categorical angles. In addition, this study employed various quantitative research techniques to analyze the database extensively, identifying trends of the global SVM application during 1995-2020, and revealing the interrelationships between imposing members, targeted products, types of SVM, and days of measure in force. Furthermore, an SVM network was established, accompanied by an exploration of key players and essential features within the network. Based on these findings, this study offered perspectives on the related implications and proposed feasible ways to alleviate the current tangled SVM warfare in a vicious circle.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- Asian Journal of WTO & International Health Law and policy
- ISSN
- 1819-5164
- 卷期
- 20卷2期
- 出版
- 2025年09月
- 頁碼
- 385–427
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000012
同期目錄
- A Conversation with Robert HudecJose Manuel Alvarez Zárate・頁 249–267
- FTAs and Fragmentation of Trade Remedy Rules—Lessons Drawn from Experiences of VietnamThi Truc Linh Phan & Jaemin Lee・頁 269–313
- Regulating Aberration: Tapping into the Ordinary Course of Trade Test vis-à-vis State-Caused Distortions in CommerceXueji Su・頁 315–350
- A Third Way Forward: The Fate of BITs in the Internal Market and China’s ChoiceHongling Ning・頁 351–384
- Tangled Warfare in a Vicious Circle: A Quantitative Analysis on the WTO Safety Valve Measures and NetworkXia Luo・頁 385–427
- The Precautionary Principle as a General Principle of International Law and Global Health LawThanh Hải Đoàn・頁 429–485
- A Book Review on Chios Carmody "A Communitarian Theory of WTO Law" (Cambridge University Press, 2024)Shin-Yi Peng・頁 487–493