The Precautionary Principle as a General Principle of International Law and Global Health Law
Ph.D. Candidate, Bioethics Centre, University of Otago, New Zealand.
摘要
Repercussions of the COVID-19 pandemic have been alleged to be attributed to the failure of the World Health Organization (hereinafter “WHO”) and states to employ the precautionary principle. In this vein, there have been calls for the precautionary principle to be included in the 2005 International Health Regulations (hereinafter “IHR”). Notwithstanding, the precautionary principle has been a subject of controversy. But what is the precautionary principle? Is it true that the precautionary principle is contrary to the object and purpose of global health law? Why did states invoke the precautionary principle? Can and how can the precautionary principle make any meaningful contribution to global health law? This paper argues that the precautionary principle is a general principle of international law, with no exception concerning global health law. However, global health law takes a restrictive approach to the precautionary principle, which is not in line with the approach of other fields of international and supranational law (hereinafter “international law”). Interestingly, global health law does not offer as much protection to health as other fields of international law. Thus, the precautionary principle and broadly international law have implications for and can contribute meaningfully to the global health project.
Abstract
Repercussions of the COVID-19 pandemic have been alleged to be attributed to the failure of the World Health Organization (hereinafter “WHO”) and states to employ the precautionary principle. In this vein, there have been calls for the precautionary principle to be included in the 2005 International Health Regulations (hereinafter “IHR”). Notwithstanding, the precautionary principle has been a subject of controversy. But what is the precautionary principle? Is it true that the precautionary principle is contrary to the object and purpose of global health law? Why did states invoke the precautionary principle? Can and how can the precautionary principle make any meaningful contribution to global health law? This paper argues that the precautionary principle is a general principle of international law, with no exception concerning global health law. However, global health law takes a restrictive approach to the precautionary principle, which is not in line with the approach of other fields of international and supranational law (hereinafter “international law”). Interestingly, global health law does not offer as much protection to health as other fields of international law. Thus, the precautionary principle and broadly international law have implications for and can contribute meaningfully to the global health project.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- Asian Journal of WTO & International Health Law and policy
- ISSN
- 1819-5164
- 卷期
- 20卷2期
- 出版
- 2025年09月
- 頁碼
- 429–485
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000013
同期目錄
- A Conversation with Robert HudecJose Manuel Alvarez Zárate・頁 249–267
- FTAs and Fragmentation of Trade Remedy Rules—Lessons Drawn from Experiences of VietnamThi Truc Linh Phan & Jaemin Lee・頁 269–313
- Regulating Aberration: Tapping into the Ordinary Course of Trade Test vis-à-vis State-Caused Distortions in CommerceXueji Su・頁 315–350
- A Third Way Forward: The Fate of BITs in the Internal Market and China’s ChoiceHongling Ning・頁 351–384
- Tangled Warfare in a Vicious Circle: A Quantitative Analysis on the WTO Safety Valve Measures and NetworkXia Luo・頁 385–427
- The Precautionary Principle as a General Principle of International Law and Global Health LawThanh Hải Đoàn・頁 429–485
- A Book Review on Chios Carmody "A Communitarian Theory of WTO Law" (Cambridge University Press, 2024)Shin-Yi Peng・頁 487–493