State-to-State Mediation: Perspectives from India
Indian Institute of Management Calcutta (India); Clarus Law Associates (India)
摘要
State-to-state mediation as a mechanism for settlement of international disputes has significant potential as a reliable alternative to the predominantly adversarial system of international dispute resolution. India has historically shown an aversion towards litigation and has preferred softer techniques and diplomatic resolution of state conflicts. As an original member of the United Nations Charter, India has endorsed the policies of pacific settlement of disputes. This philosophy is embodied in the Indian Constitution as well as its international diplomacy through adherence to the principles of Panchsheel and its support for alternative dispute settlement Institutions such as the Asian-African Legal Consultative Organization (AALCO) regional arbitration centres. The inherent recognition of the value for amicable and peaceful settlement of disputes is also reflected in India’s attitude towards disputes in the trade and investment arena. Given this background, India may be open to the idea of exploring the availability of neutral third party mediation processes, as is sought to be presented under the Asia-Pacific Regional Mediation Organization (hereinafter “ARMO”). This paper attempts to bring out the Indian perspective on State-to-State mediation and the significance of ARMO from an Indian stand point.
Abstract
State-to-state mediation as a mechanism for settlement of international disputes has significant potential as a reliable alternative to the predominantly adversarial system of international dispute resolution. India has historically shown an aversion towards litigation and has preferred softer techniques and diplomatic resolution of state conflicts. As an original member of the United Nations Charter, India has endorsed the policies of pacific settlement of disputes. This philosophy is embodied in the Indian Constitution as well as its international diplomacy through adherence to the principles of Panchsheel and its support for alternative dispute settlement Institutions such as the Asian-African Legal Consultative Organization (AALCO) regional arbitration centres. The inherent recognition of the value for amicable and peaceful settlement of disputes is also reflected in India’s attitude towards disputes in the trade and investment arena. Given this background, India may be open to the idea of exploring the availability of neutral third party mediation processes, as is sought to be presented under the Asia-Pacific Regional Mediation Organization (hereinafter “ARMO”). This paper attempts to bring out the Indian perspective on State-to-State mediation and the significance of ARMO from an Indian stand point.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- Asian Journal of WTO & International Health Law and policy
- ISSN
- 1819-5164
- 卷期
- 13卷1期
- 出版
- 2018年03月
- 頁碼
- 135–144
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000130
同期目錄
- The Launch of the ARMO Initiative and a Food for Thought for the Debates on the Most Suitable Dispute Settlement Mechanism for the Asia-Pacific Region羅昌發(Chang-fa Lo)・頁 1–4
- Draft “Agreement on the Establishment of the Asia-Pacific Regional Mediation Organization”Chang-fa Lo;Junji Nakagawa;Rajesh Sharma;Tsai-yu Lin;Lisa Toohey;Joseph Wira Koesnaidi;Jaemin Lee;Tomohiko Kobayashi;R.V. Anuradha;Julien Chaisse & R. Rajesh Babu・頁 5–16
- Draft “Rules of Procedure for Mediation Conducted Under the Asia-Pacific Regional Mediation Organization”Chang-fa Lo;Junji Nakagawa;Rajesh Sharma;Tsai-yu Lin;Lisa Toohey;Joseph Wira Koesnaidi;Jaemin Lee;Tomohiko Kobayashi;R.V. Anuradha;Julien Chaisse & R. Rajesh Babu・頁 17–26
- A New Approach for the Settlement of Regional Disputes to Maintain Dynamic Stability—A Selective Elaboration of the Draft Agreement on the Establishment of the Asia-Pacific Regional Mediation OrganizationChang-fa Lo;Janice Lee・頁 27–46
- Mediation Rules of the ARMO for State-to-State Disputes: Effective, Efficient and PracticalRajesh Sharma・頁 47–62
- Enhancing Mediation in the Asia-Pacific: The Interaction of the ARMO Regime with Existing Dispute Settlement MechanismsLisa Toohey・頁 63–80
- Settling International Disputes Through Mediation—Establishing a New International Organization in Asia Pacific and Jurisdictional IssuesJaemin Lee・頁 81–112
- If You Build It, They Will Come: On the Institutional Arrangements of the ARMOTomohiko Kobayashi・頁 113–118
- Making It a Treaty Obligation: Enforcement of Mediated Settlement Agreements Under the ARMO林彩瑜(Tsai-yu Lin)・頁 119–134
- State-to-State Mediation: Perspectives from IndiaR. Rajesh Babu;R.V. Anuradha・頁 135–144
- The Assessment of Asia-Pacific Regional Mediation Organization (ARMO): From the Perspective of IndonesiaJoseph Wira Koesnaidi・頁 145–157
- Outsiders’ Perspective on China’s Possible Participation in the Asia-Pacific Regional Mediation Organization—Toward Peaceful and Prosperous Coexistence羅昌發(Chang-fa Lo);羅致遠(Chih-yuan Lo);黃信維(Xin-Wei Huang);施煜芳(Yu-Fang Shih)・頁 159–176
- An Assessment of ARMO from the Perspective of Taiwan薛景文(Ching-wen Hsueh) & 羅懋瑋Mao-wei Lo・頁 177–204
- Necessary Measure Under the SPS AgreementElbinsar Purba・頁 205–232
- Procurement of the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank: Five Legal IssuesGU Bin・頁 233–267
- A Book Review of Chang-fa Lo’s “Treaty Interpretation Under the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties: A New Round of Codification”Mitsuo Matsushita・頁 269–273