以國之名:比較文學學派知識的旅行
In the Name of Nation: Knowledge Travel in the Case of Comparative Literature Schools
中國南開大學文學院講師(Lecturer, School of Literature, Nankai University, China)
- 類型
- 一般論文
- 卷期
- 50卷4期
- 出版
- 2021年12月
- 頁碼
- 011–042
- 編號
- NTUEJ00001344
你目前的連線不在校內範圍,所以無法開啟全文。書目與摘要不受限制;回到校內網路後重新整理本頁,全文就會直接顯示。
摘要
作為二十世紀中葉美國的學術史事件,比較文學學派論爭的「名」與「實」
之間有較大的差異:在「名」的層面,是美國學派對法國學派的批判與反
叛;在「實」的層面,則是新一代學者對傳統歐陸比較文學的繼承和發
展。在1970 年代,臺灣學者在選擇追隨美國學派的同時,也將以國家為
單位的學派納入比較文學的知識建構中,進而在錯綜複雜的語境中將學
派簡化和對立化,更推出了「中國學派」的構想。到了1980 年代的中國
大陸,關於學派的二元想像被繼續擴大,學派對立的故事被轉化為知識
的進化圖譜。在1990 年代的全球化語境中,「中國學派」在中國大陸也改
換意味,成為中西關係想像的文化表徵。學派曲折的旅行過程不僅反映
了中國大陸比較文學與臺灣比較文學之間的密切聯繫,而且也折射了知
識生產與國家/國際政治之間的複雜關係。對學派等比較文學知識的建
構史展開批判性研究,本身就是一種別具意義的比較文學實踐。
Abstract
The notion of “school” in the field of Chinese comparative literature is a
product of knowledge travel. Originating from mid-20th-century American
academia, the internal debates concerning schools in comparative literature
varied widely in name and substance: while nominally the contention pointed
to the American school’s critical revolt against the French school, its true
nature was America’s inheritance and development of European comparatism.
In the 1970s, when Taiwan comparatists chose to follow the American
school, they imported such national school labels into their own knowledge
construction and strengthened the dichotomy between the two schools,
while simultaneously proposing the concept of “Chinese school.” In the
1980s, Mainland Chinese comparatists pushed that dichotomy up to another
level, transforming the story of schools into an evolutionary lineage. In the
1990s, the “Chinese school” was then reconceived by Chinese comparatists
to symbolize the new relationship between China and the West. The case of
“schools” shows the close relationship between comparative literature in Taiwan
and Mainland China as well as refracts the complex relationship between
(inter)national politics and knowledge production. I contend that the critical
study of knowledge construction in the history of comparative literature is
itself a special and meaningful kind of comparative literature studies.