To Lead or not to Lead – Reverting President Trump’s Retreat from United States’ Traditional Leading Role in Promoting Human Rights Through Trade
國立臺灣大學法律學系(Department of Law, National Taiwan University)
摘要
Traditionally, the United States has long been the promoter of human rights (especially labor rights) protection through trade measures and agreements. But the “America first” policy adopted by the Trump Administration has created negative impressions of the United States being hostile toward existing Free Trade Agreements (hereinafter “FTAs”) and being unenthusiastic about promoting labor rights or human rights protection through FTAs. The paper argues that the “America first” policy and the human rights promotion can co-exist. If the United States can make it clear that its position of promoting human rights and labor rights protection through its FTAs and its Generalized System of Preferences (hereinafter “GSP”) has not been changed under the “America first” policy, it could enhance the justification of its position in renegotiating agreements with its trading partners. On the other hand, if the impression that the United States is giving up its leadership in promoting human rights and labor rights protection through trade measures and agreements is continued, the justification of its policy in renegotiating the trade agreements would be weakened. Hence it should be important for the United States to remove such negative impression of retreating from its traditional leading role.
Abstract
Traditionally, the United States has long been the promoter of human rights (especially labor rights) protection through trade measures and agreements. But the “America first” policy adopted by the Trump Administration has created negative impressions of the United States being hostile toward existing Free Trade Agreements (hereinafter “FTAs”) and being unenthusiastic about promoting labor rights or human rights protection through FTAs. The paper argues that the “America first” policy and the human rights promotion can co-exist. If the United States can make it clear that its position of promoting human rights and labor rights protection through its FTAs and its Generalized System of Preferences (hereinafter “GSP”) has not been changed under the “America first” policy, it could enhance the justification of its position in renegotiating agreements with its trading partners. On the other hand, if the impression that the United States is giving up its leadership in promoting human rights and labor rights protection through trade measures and agreements is continued, the justification of its policy in renegotiating the trade agreements would be weakened. Hence it should be important for the United States to remove such negative impression of retreating from its traditional leading role.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- Asian Journal of WTO & International Health Law and policy
- ISSN
- 1819-5164
- 卷期
- 12卷2期
- 出版
- 2017年09月
- 頁碼
- 227–246
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000138
同期目錄
- Preface for the AJWH’s Special Issue on President Trump’s Trade Policy – Proper Assessment of the Possible Disruption to the Status Quo羅昌發(Chang-fa Lo)・頁 223–225
- To Lead or not to Lead – Reverting President Trump’s Retreat from United States’ Traditional Leading Role in Promoting Human Rights Through Trade羅昌發(Chang-fa Lo)・頁 227–246
- Trump’s Trade Policy: Discerning Between Rhetoric and RealityDeborah Elms & Bhargav Sriganesh・頁 247–264
- Making Trade Policy Great Again: What Policymakers Should Learn from Trump’s ElectionFernando Dias Simões・頁 265–288
- Policy & Legal Issues Raised by the Proposed U.S. Border Adjustable TaxAndrew D. Mitchell & Emma Gan・頁 289–310
- To Judge the “Self-Judging” Security Exception Under the GATT 1994 – A Systematic Approach陳在方(Tsai-fang Chen)・頁 311–356
- Undeniable Obligations to Gaia: U.S. Remaining Investment Obligations After Its Withdrawal from the Paris Agreement薛景文(Ching-Wen Hsueh)・頁 357–380
- Revisiting the Legal Nature of “Un-Signing” an Unratified Treaty: Broader Implications of U.S.’ Withdrawal from the TPPTomohiko Kobayashi・頁 381–404
- TPP-11 as a Means to Revive the TPP After U.S.’ WithdrawalJunji Nakagawa・頁 405–420
- Skepticism, Unilateralism or Ultimatumism?: Trump Administration’s Trade Policy and the Korea–U.S. FTAJaemin Lee・頁 421–462
- A Book Review of “International Economic Law and Governance: Essays in Honour of Mitsuo Matsushita” – Edited by Julien Chaisse and Tsai-yu LinShintaro Hamanaka・頁 463–469