Revisiting the Legal Nature of “Un-Signing” an Unratified Treaty: Broader Implications of U.S.’ Withdrawal from the TPP
Otaru University of Commerce (Japan)
摘要
This article focuses on the legal issues arising from treaty withdrawal after signing but before ratification, as is the case in the United States (hereinafter “U.S.”) withdrawal from the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement (hereinafter “TPP”). This article attempts to shed light on the definition of “withdrawal” (or “un-signing”) because it can make a practical difference to the fate of the TPP.
More specifically, we consider the legal nature of the U.S. withdrawal and its broader implications for the other signatories. First, is the U.S. still acting within the framework of the TPP or is it already out? Second, what impact does this U.S. action have on the legal status of the other original signatories of the TPP? Third, is the U.S. liable for violating its obligation to not frustrate the object and purpose of the treaty at hand? Finally, what can the 11 original signatories learn from the exit of the U.S. to revive the TPP without U.S. involvement?
Our major arguments are that the U.S. still remains an original signatory to the TPP, despite its notorious notification of withdrawal in January 2017. On the other hand, other original signatories that have already ratified are not exempt from the interim obligation of not frustrating the object and purpose based solely on “undue delay” caused by the U.S.’s unilateral notification of withdrawal. In addition, other original signatories are not eligible to claim damages against the U.S. due to their acquiescence, and the U.S. cannot claim damages for the subsequent actions of other original signatories because the current situation was created by the U.S. itself. Finally, the other original signatories have several options to avoid a similar incident in the future.
Abstract
This article focuses on the legal issues arising from treaty withdrawal after signing but before ratification, as is the case in the United States (hereinafter “U.S.”) withdrawal from the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement (hereinafter “TPP”). This article attempts to shed light on the definition of “withdrawal” (or “un-signing”) because it can make a practical difference to the fate of the TPP.
More specifically, we consider the legal nature of the U.S. withdrawal and its broader implications for the other signatories. First, is the U.S. still acting within the framework of the TPP or is it already out? Second, what impact does this U.S. action have on the legal status of the other original signatories of the TPP? Third, is the U.S. liable for violating its obligation to not frustrate the object and purpose of the treaty at hand? Finally, what can the 11 original signatories learn from the exit of the U.S. to revive the TPP without U.S. involvement?
Our major arguments are that the U.S. still remains an original signatory to the TPP, despite its notorious notification of withdrawal in January 2017. On the other hand, other original signatories that have already ratified are not exempt from the interim obligation of not frustrating the object and purpose based solely on “undue delay” caused by the U.S.’s unilateral notification of withdrawal. In addition, other original signatories are not eligible to claim damages against the U.S. due to their acquiescence, and the U.S. cannot claim damages for the subsequent actions of other original signatories because the current situation was created by the U.S. itself. Finally, the other original signatories have several options to avoid a similar incident in the future.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- Asian Journal of WTO & International Health Law and policy
- ISSN
- 1819-5164
- 卷期
- 12卷2期
- 出版
- 2017年09月
- 頁碼
- 381–404
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000144
同期目錄
- Preface for the AJWH’s Special Issue on President Trump’s Trade Policy – Proper Assessment of the Possible Disruption to the Status Quo羅昌發(Chang-fa Lo)・頁 223–225
- To Lead or not to Lead – Reverting President Trump’s Retreat from United States’ Traditional Leading Role in Promoting Human Rights Through Trade羅昌發(Chang-fa Lo)・頁 227–246
- Trump’s Trade Policy: Discerning Between Rhetoric and RealityDeborah Elms & Bhargav Sriganesh・頁 247–264
- Making Trade Policy Great Again: What Policymakers Should Learn from Trump’s ElectionFernando Dias Simões・頁 265–288
- Policy & Legal Issues Raised by the Proposed U.S. Border Adjustable TaxAndrew D. Mitchell & Emma Gan・頁 289–310
- To Judge the “Self-Judging” Security Exception Under the GATT 1994 – A Systematic Approach陳在方(Tsai-fang Chen)・頁 311–356
- Undeniable Obligations to Gaia: U.S. Remaining Investment Obligations After Its Withdrawal from the Paris Agreement薛景文(Ching-Wen Hsueh)・頁 357–380
- Revisiting the Legal Nature of “Un-Signing” an Unratified Treaty: Broader Implications of U.S.’ Withdrawal from the TPPTomohiko Kobayashi・頁 381–404
- TPP-11 as a Means to Revive the TPP After U.S.’ WithdrawalJunji Nakagawa・頁 405–420
- Skepticism, Unilateralism or Ultimatumism?: Trump Administration’s Trade Policy and the Korea–U.S. FTAJaemin Lee・頁 421–462
- A Book Review of “International Economic Law and Governance: Essays in Honour of Mitsuo Matsushita” – Edited by Julien Chaisse and Tsai-yu LinShintaro Hamanaka・頁 463–469