臺大學術期刊資料庫NTU Journal Database

不可能悅納(寄生)昆蟲?:動物倫理的蟲蟲危機

The Limits of Hospitality?: Repositioning the Status of (Parasitic) Insects in Animal Ethics

黃宗慧(Tsung-huei Huang)

國立臺灣大學外國語文學系教授(Professor, Department of Foreign Languages and Literatures, National Taiwan University.)

類型
論文
卷期
47卷2期
出版
2018年06月
頁碼
009–046
編號
NTUEJ00001452
全文限校內本刊全文只能在臺大校內網路閱讀。

你目前的連線不在校內範圍,所以無法開啟全文。書目與摘要不受限制;回到校內網路後重新整理本頁,全文就會直接顯示。

摘要

動物研究者在探討倫理議題時,經常會援引德希達(Jacques Derrida)所謂悅納異己的觀念,但這樣的訴求經常面臨的質疑是:難道就算面對(寄生)昆蟲,我們也必須無條件地接納,即使會因此造成自身的風險?由於在類似的質疑之中,往往是(寄生)昆蟲被挑出來作為動物倫理的思考與實踐跨不過的門檻,本論文因此企圖探討,蟲在動物研究中的邊陲位置,是否有助於我們進行更基進的思考,從而讓蟲也有被納入倫理考量的機會。論文第一部分將以列維納斯(Emmanuel Levinas)的理論思考昆蟲的倫理面貌,也將對比昆蟲如何以擬人的面貌出現在我們的文化中;第二部分帶入德希達的動物倫理觀,討論諸如動物與人是「共死者」(commourans)等概念,為何似乎也不能有效扭轉我們視昆蟲生命為無物的傾向,並以凸顯昆蟲「可塑性」的藝術家法默(Tessa Farmer)其作品為參照,思考昆蟲不被視為共死者的原因,是否正在於其強大的生存本能;第三節則聚焦於可塑性此主題,指出人類社會既利用並依賴了昆蟲的這種可塑性,就有倫理責任進一步去理解人與蟲之間的依存關係,並主張重新思考「人的智性vs.蟲的本能」這種高低位階的問題所在,期能為辨識蟲的倫理面貌帶來一線希望。

Abstract

Animal ethicists often draw on Jacques Derrida’s theory of hospitality to
claim that nonhuman animals warrant our moral consideration. However, their
advocacy is contested by questions like “Are we able to enter into a relation
of care with insects or parasites which are inimical to human health?” In this
paper, I will inquire why insects or parasites seem to constitute insurmountable
barriers to our ethical behavior. The first section of this essay explores how
insects, lacking a Levinasian notion of face which demands our response/
responsibility, are anthropomorphized in literature and mass culture, and
how their appalling appearance thereby hinders our ethical access to them.
The second section uses Derrida’s notion of commourans to explain why his
philosophy also seems insufficient to make us include insects in our circle of
moral concern. Using Tessa Farmer’s artwork as an example, I analyze how the
plasticity of insects precludes us from seeing them as our co-diers. The third
section begins with how humans have exploited the plasticity of insects to turn
them into our companions of war. I also question the hypothesis that insects
are eminently instinctive and devoid of intelligence. The paper concludes that
the reconsideration of the “instinct/intelligence” dichotomy may pave the
way for the deconstruction of anthropocentrism and, hopefully, enable us to
recognize an insect’s “face” in the ethical sense.

關鍵詞

程式與 AI 助手可以改用資料介面(JSON、MCP),查詢比讀頁面快。給程式與 AI 代理的存取說明