臺大學術期刊資料庫NTU Journal Database

從文物真品收藏到文創商品行銷:歷史文物的產業化進程──從《高堡奇人》中的二元思維與資本主義邏輯談起

From Historical Objects Collection to Cultural and Creative Commodities Marketing: Exploring Dualism and the Capitalistic Logic in The Man in the High Castle

曾瑞華(Laurie Jui-hua Tseng)

國立臺東大學英美語文學系副教授(Associate Professor, Department of English, National Taitung University)

類型
論文
卷期
47卷1期
出版
2018年03月
頁碼
009–044
編號
NTUEJ00001459
全文限校內本刊全文只能在臺大校內網路閱讀。

你目前的連線不在校內範圍,所以無法開啟全文。書目與摘要不受限制;回到校內網路後重新整理本頁,全文就會直接顯示。

摘要

本文透過紀傑克論諾斯底主義與資本主義的觀點閱讀迪克的架空歷史小說《高堡奇人》。透過小說中架空歷史的敘事結構與文物收藏的故事情節,本文指出,儘管作者原本企圖藉由對虛實的顛覆與對文創複製商品的抗拒擺脫卑劣的物質世界,以臻至完美的靈知世界,其對真實的執著(一如其明顯可見的諾斯底主義色彩)不僅沒有讓他更接近真實的理想世界,反而讓他因僵固化(或物化)的價值理念更進一步地深陷於虛幻的觀念迷宮──或即紀傑克理論中所描述的最具法西斯主義色彩的利比多轉化機制:資本主義體制。例如,儘管從事歷史文物與原創手工藝品買賣的契爾丹先生反對在開模量產文創商品的產銷過程中,原創的美國手工藝品只能做量產商品的模子,對於資本主義抹殺原創真品價值的運作更是強烈不滿,其對原創真品的看重事實上仍是與資本主義商品區隔的運作邏輯互嵌的。基於此,他所拒絕量產的文創商品不僅不會消失,反而得以藉由其所值的價格流通市場,間接鞏固他所批判的資本/重利主義。全文共分四節,首節論證小說中的二元思維與諾斯底主義色彩,次節闡述紀傑克有關諾斯底二元思維與資本主義發展邏輯的論述,第三節
從小說中與文物收藏及交易有關的細節探討真品收藏與資本主義運作邏
輯的相關性,並藉以反思當代社會中商品化歷史文物充斥的現況,末節
則從紀傑克的觀點探討如何以更有建設性的態度面對歷史文物的產業化
過程。

Abstract

This article explores the dualism and capitalistic logic inherent in Philip
K. Dick’s alternative history novel The Man in the High Castle by using Slavoj
Žižek’s theory on Gnosticism and capitalistic logic. Through an analysis (based
on Žižek’s critique on the dualism of Gnosticism) of the futile resistance to the
industrialization of the historical objects in the novel, this article, by revealing
the conceptual trap of dualism, explains why the author, in spite of his attempt
to pursue the immaterial gnosis absent from the present world, still fails to
disengage himself from the material world he thought he would be disengaged
from. The article comprises of four sections. The first section uncovers the
dualistic order and the Gnostic element of the novel. The second section
explores Žižek’s view on Gnosticism and its affinity with the operation of
capitalism. The third section examines capitalism as the fundamental structure
which not only underlies the development of the novel, especially the part
involving historical objects collection and exchange, but also dominates the
development of our contemporary society where historical objects are driven to
be commercialized. Finally, on the basis of Žižek’s theory of non-action the last
section attempts to propose a way to confront the capitalization of historical
objects better than Dick’s Gnostic approach.

關鍵詞

程式與 AI 助手可以改用資料介面(JSON、MCP),查詢比讀頁面快。給程式與 AI 代理的存取說明