薩德,200 年後:惡的實踐理性批判
Sade, 200 Years After: Critique of the Practical Reason of Evil
國立台北藝術大學藝術跨域研究所(Graduate Institute of Trans-disciplinary Arts, Taipei National University of the
Arts)
- 類型
- 專輯論文
- 卷期
- 43卷2期
- 出版
- 2014年06月
- 頁碼
- 153–179
- 編號
- NTUEJ00001579
你目前的連線不在校內範圍,所以無法開啟全文。書目與摘要不受限制;回到校內網路後重新整理本頁,全文就會直接顯示。
摘要
薩德書寫的不可化約核心並不是色情而是觀念,不是欲望而是真
理,不是故事而是實踐,本文討論薩德如何由經驗描敘到先驗觀念,由
色情到色情學,或由虛構到真理。主要的問題是:薩德透過書寫在語言
平面上所從事的思想事業究竟是什麼?薩德的作品中總是有一個必須而
且僅能由實踐證成的「惡的實踐理性」,強勢的界限經驗與遽烈的辯證翻
轉形構了此實踐的最主要特徵。薩德書寫的賭注並不是浪蕩,不管其小
說如何充滿著淫穢、犯罪或瀆神,其最終要迫顯的仍是作為觀念的惡。
正是在此有書寫的一切困難,以及由此困難所激生的各種語言的雄辯與
思想的拗折。他的每一個故事都述說著某一變態者的特異存有,但這些
存有在彰顯其差異的同時也都共鳴著「單一與相同意義」,這便是薩德作
品裡的「惡的單義性」。
Abstract
The irreducible goal of Sade’s work does not concern erotism but the Idea,
not desire but truth, not history but practice. This paper focuses on the passage
from the empirical description to the transcendental Idea, from pornography
to “pornology,” or from fiction to truth. The central problem is: what is the
enterprise of thought that Sade attempts to build through his writings? In
Sade, the “practical reason of evil” is characterized by the experience of limit
and the dialectical transformation. The stake of his writings, however, do not
pertain to debauchery, crimes, profanation and so forth; the most essential for
Sade is the idea of evil—the idea from which all difficulties are derived, and
through which the extraordinary movements of Sade’s philosophy emerge.
Sade’s tales reveal the singular existence of the pervert, but each resonates with
the “one and only sense” while representing its own differences, thus suggesting
the univocity of evil in his work.