How to Balance International Trade and Public Health in the Face of Emerging Infectious Diseases? — Reflections and Research Based on the Implementation of “Additional Health Measures” in COVID-19
PhD Candidate, Faculty of Law, University of Hong Kong
摘要
This article delves into the efficacy of general public policy exceptions within International Investment Agreements (hereinafter “IIAs”) against the backdrop of the unprecedented global health crisis precipitated by the COVID-19 pandemic. By empirically surveying the use of general public policy exceptions in IIAs, the research highlights a discernible trend towards the incorporation of such exceptions in new-generation IIAs, aimed at reconciling investment protection with the host state’s regulatory autonomy for public welfare. However, the examination of arbitral jurisprudence reveals the tribunals’ challenges in coherently and effectively applying these exceptions, often resulting in outcomes that diverge from the contracting states’ expectations and the objectives underlying these treaty innovations. This analysis is particularly important and timely in the context of the COVID-19 crisis, where the potential surge in investor-state disputes arising from pandemic-related regulatory measures poses pressing questions about the efficacy and scope of general public policy exceptions. However, the prevailing uncertainties in arbitral interpretations may cast a significant shadow on the prospective utility of these exceptions. In light of these challenges, this article calls for a holistic reform of IIAs and a recalibration of arbitral practice, advocating for enhanced engagement with World Trade Organization jurisprudence and the provision of explicit clarifications within IIAs to ensure that general public policy exceptions fulfil their intended purpose.
Abstract
This article delves into the efficacy of general public policy exceptions within International Investment Agreements (hereinafter “IIAs”) against the backdrop of the unprecedented global health crisis precipitated by the COVID-19 pandemic. By empirically surveying the use of general public policy exceptions in IIAs, the research highlights a discernible trend towards the incorporation of such exceptions in new-generation IIAs, aimed at reconciling investment protection with the host state’s regulatory autonomy for public welfare. However, the examination of arbitral jurisprudence reveals the tribunals’ challenges in coherently and effectively applying these exceptions, often resulting in outcomes that diverge from the contracting states’ expectations and the objectives underlying these treaty innovations. This analysis is particularly important and timely in the context of the COVID-19 crisis, where the potential surge in investor-state disputes arising from pandemic-related regulatory measures poses pressing questions about the efficacy and scope of general public policy exceptions. However, the prevailing uncertainties in arbitral interpretations may cast a significant shadow on the prospective utility of these exceptions. In light of these challenges, this article calls for a holistic reform of IIAs and a recalibration of arbitral practice, advocating for enhanced engagement with World Trade Organization jurisprudence and the provision of explicit clarifications within IIAs to ensure that general public policy exceptions fulfil their intended purpose.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- Asian Journal of WTO & International Health Law and policy
- ISSN
- 1819-5164
- 卷期
- 20卷1期
- 出版
- 2025年03月
- 頁碼
- 127–176
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000018
同期目錄
- The Application of International Climate Change Law in International Investment Arbitration: Addressing the DeficienciesSheng Zhang & Ni Li・頁 1–40
- Unveiling Data as an Investment in International Investment Law: China’s Quest towards Harmonious Adaptation and Developmental ParadigmsXinlong Yang・頁 41–90
- Anti-Enforcement Loops of Renewable Energy Awards Against Spain: Risks and Anti-AbuseLiping Huang・頁 91–126
- How to Balance International Trade and Public Health in the Face of Emerging Infectious Diseases? — Reflections and Research Based on the Implementation of “Additional Health Measures” in COVID-19Yi Tang・頁 127–176
- General Public Policy Exceptions in International Investment Agreements (IIAs): Opportunities and Challenges in Times of Global Health CrisisJiabao Duan・頁 177–208
- Looking Outside or Looking Inside?: The Effects of Trade Bureaucracy Design on Trade Dispute BehaviorJung Hyun Han & RyuGyung Park・頁 209–248