Creator of Value, Establisher of Vital Norms: Georges Canguilhem’s Philosophy of the Life Sciences
Professor, Department of English, Tamkang University, Taiwan
- 類型
- 特別企劃:研究論文
- 卷期
- 50期
- 出版
- 2023年12月
- 頁碼
- 005–019
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000186
你目前的連線不在校內範圍,所以無法開啟全文。書目與摘要不受限制;回到校內網路後重新整理本頁,全文就會直接顯示。
摘要
This paper begins with an examination of a genealogy of philosophical reflections on
health and illness from Friedrich Nietzsche to Georges Canguilhem and Gilles
Deleuze. While Nietzsche’s inspiration to Deleuze has been widely acknowledged, lit tle attention has been paid to how Canguilhem’s philosophy of the life sciences fol lows Nietzsche and later affects Deleuze. Canguilhem claims that health is one’s feel ing of confidence in life; health is when a living being feels it creates values and estab lishes its own vital norms. The notion of individuality plays a significant role in
Canguilhem’s philosophy of the life sciences. Individuality is not only constituted by a
living being who determines how to react; for Canguilhem, individuality refers to a
living being as well as its relation to the milieu. An individual is not pre-given; instead,
in selecting and responding to its milieu, it is individuated. Understood in a biological
sense, the individual, when creating a norm, makes a judgment based on feeling. While
a norm is created, the assessment is where values are posited. For Canguilhem, to live
is to evaluate, to seek the sense of the organism’s choice. Hence the notion of individ uality is considered as an axiological rather than an ontological one. This paper is
composed of three parts: the living and its milieu, individuality and valuation, and
Canguilhem and contemporary medical issues. I intend to examine why and how
Canguilhem’s notion of individuality is tied to value judgements, what influence
Nietzsche has on Canguilhem, and how Canguilhem’s thoughtful ideas of individ uality can help us critically reflect on contemporary debates about personalized
medicine.
Abstract
This paper begins with an examination of a genealogy of philosophical reflections on
health and illness from Friedrich Nietzsche to Georges Canguilhem and Gilles
Deleuze. While Nietzsche’s inspiration to Deleuze has been widely acknowledged, lit tle attention has been paid to how Canguilhem’s philosophy of the life sciences fol lows Nietzsche and later affects Deleuze. Canguilhem claims that health is one’s feel ing of confidence in life; health is when a living being feels it creates values and estab lishes its own vital norms. The notion of individuality plays a significant role in
Canguilhem’s philosophy of the life sciences. Individuality is not only constituted by a
living being who determines how to react; for Canguilhem, individuality refers to a
living being as well as its relation to the milieu. An individual is not pre-given; instead,
in selecting and responding to its milieu, it is individuated. Understood in a biological
sense, the individual, when creating a norm, makes a judgment based on feeling. While
a norm is created, the assessment is where values are posited. For Canguilhem, to live
is to evaluate, to seek the sense of the organism’s choice. Hence the notion of individ uality is considered as an axiological rather than an ontological one. This paper is
composed of three parts: the living and its milieu, individuality and valuation, and
Canguilhem and contemporary medical issues. I intend to examine why and how
Canguilhem’s notion of individuality is tied to value judgements, what influence
Nietzsche has on Canguilhem, and how Canguilhem’s thoughtful ideas of individ uality can help us critically reflect on contemporary debates about personalized
medicine.