Legal and Economic Analysis of US Antidumping Rules on Global Overcapacity as a Particular Market Situation
Kyounghwa Kim, Assistant Professor, Department of International Trade, Konkuk University
Jaeyoun Roh, Associate Professor, School of International Economics & Business, Yeungnam University
摘要
With the increasing importance of global overcapacity as a pressing international trade issue, this study analyses whether market distortions caused by overcapacity can be adequately addressed within the framework of the antidumping (hereinafter “AD”) system from legal and economic perspectives. The new AD proceeding rule of the United States clarifies global overcapacity as one of the “particular market situations (hereinafter “PMS”)” that may distort production costs, thereby allowing the United States Department of Commerce (hereinafter “DOC”) to adjust the production cost upward in establishing constructed value. Legally, this paper analyses whether such cost adjustments are compatible with the Agreement on Implementation of Article VI of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade 1994, particularly under Article 2.2.1.1, which emphasizes the use of exporters’ actual records unless compelling reasons justify otherwise. Economically, this study assesses the global steel overcapacity problem, its market impacts, and whether it can be reliably treated as a PMS. Furthermore, it evaluates the methodology used by the DOC to quantify overcapacity-induced distortions in input costs. While overcapacity can contribute to market distortions, its treatment as a PMS must be carefully scrutinized legally and economically, and any cost adjustment must rely on robust and transparent empirical methods.
Abstract
With the increasing importance of global overcapacity as a pressing international trade issue, this study analyses whether market distortions caused by overcapacity can be adequately addressed within the framework of the antidumping (hereinafter “AD”) system from legal and economic perspectives. The new AD proceeding rule of the United States clarifies global overcapacity as one of the “particular market situations (hereinafter “PMS”)” that may distort production costs, thereby allowing the United States Department of Commerce (hereinafter “DOC”) to adjust the production cost upward in establishing constructed value. Legally, this paper analyses whether such cost adjustments are compatible with the Agreement on Implementation of Article VI of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade 1994, particularly under Article 2.2.1.1, which emphasizes the use of exporters’ actual records unless compelling reasons justify otherwise. Economically, this study assesses the global steel overcapacity problem, its market impacts, and whether it can be reliably treated as a PMS. Furthermore, it evaluates the methodology used by the DOC to quantify overcapacity-induced distortions in input costs. While overcapacity can contribute to market distortions, its treatment as a PMS must be carefully scrutinized legally and economically, and any cost adjustment must rely on robust and transparent empirical methods.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- Asian Journal of WTO & International Health Law and policy
- ISSN
- 1819-5164
- 卷期
- 21卷2期
- 出版
- 2026年09月
- 頁碼
- 335–364
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000002
同期目錄
- Evaluating National Security Measures Through the Prism of Defensive and Offensive DeploymentJoel Slawotsky・頁 287–333
- Legal and Economic Analysis of US Antidumping Rules on Global Overcapacity as a Particular Market SituationKyounghwa Kim & Jaeyoun Roh・頁 335–364
- The Risk of Investor-State Arbitration Arising from Renewable Energy Subsidy Schemes: A Caveat for Asian CountriesChen Yu・頁 365–400
- Reconstructing Enforcement in Global Health Law: Sovereignty, Incentives, and the Structural Limits of the International Health RegulationsMohammad Omar Alhejaili & Ibrahim Mathker Alotaibi・頁 401–434
- International Commitments for Test Data Protection and Their Limits in the Context of Access to Medicines amid a Pandemic Situation: The Case of COVID-19 PandemicMoniruz Zaman・頁 435–468
- Were Border Control Measures Helpful for Containing Covid-19? A Time-Series AnalysisShun-Wen Wu・頁 469–514
- A Book Review of Chang Fa Lo Unlocking WTO Decision-Making: Rebuilding Cooperative Consensus Culture to Remedy the Efficiency Deficit (Springer Nature Singapore, 2026)Lisa Toohey・頁 515–522