Study in Fairies: Arthur Conan Doyle’s Alternative Science and the Cottingley Fairy Photographs
Assistant Professor, Graduate School of Art and Design, Tama Art University, Japan
- 類型
- 一般論文
- 卷期
- 48期
- 出版
- 2022年12月
- 頁碼
- 097–121
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000205
你目前的連線不在校內範圍,所以無法開啟全文。書目與摘要不受限制;回到校內網路後重新整理本頁,全文就會直接顯示。
摘要
Arthur Conan Doyle’s involvement in what amounted to a “case” revolving around
the Cottingley Fairies, that is, the fact that he once published a number of photographs
apparently featuring fairies, claiming they showed no evidence of forgery,
has generally been considered by scholars to be simply an expression of Doyle’s
already-held belief in spiritualism. This article challenges this interpretation and
examines the investigation of the fairy photographs as part of Doyle’s development
of alternative science. Comparing Doyle’s method with those of psychical researchers
of his time and with the philosophy of science proposed by Charles
Sanders Peirce, and also looking at unpublished letters exchanged between Doyle
and others involved in the case, this article argues that Doyle, combining psychical
and spiritualist research methods, largely maintained his attitude as an investigator
in search of truth, mediating among scientists, spiritualists, and the public. This
article further suggests that, with reference to Peirce’s arguments on God, Doyle
might have “seen” fairies in the fifth fairy photograph as a result of his unique alternative
science.
Abstract
Arthur Conan Doyle’s involvement in what amounted to a “case” revolving around
the Cottingley Fairies, that is, the fact that he once published a number of photographs
apparently featuring fairies, claiming they showed no evidence of forgery,
has generally been considered by scholars to be simply an expression of Doyle’s
already-held belief in spiritualism. This article challenges this interpretation and
examines the investigation of the fairy photographs as part of Doyle’s development
of alternative science. Comparing Doyle’s method with those of psychical researchers
of his time and with the philosophy of science proposed by Charles
Sanders Peirce, and also looking at unpublished letters exchanged between Doyle
and others involved in the case, this article argues that Doyle, combining psychical
and spiritualist research methods, largely maintained his attitude as an investigator
in search of truth, mediating among scientists, spiritualists, and the public. This
article further suggests that, with reference to Peirce’s arguments on God, Doyle
might have “seen” fairies in the fifth fairy photograph as a result of his unique alternative
science.