從法案到法律—立委立法行為之實證分析:「公共事務類」法案之個案分析
Bill to Law-A Practical Analysis of Legislative Behavior in Legislative Yuan: A Case Study of Public Affair Bill
國立臺北大學亞洲研究中心博士後研究員,國立台灣師範大學國際與僑教學院兼任助理教授
摘要
立法院常設委員會乃法案審查之最重要機制,而立法委員在審查法案過程中可能直接或間接影響立法結果,因此,立委在常設委員會審查法案的各種立法行為便顯得十分重要。
本文旨在研究立法委員於常設委員會審查法案時的五種主要立法行為,包括:連署、發言、保留院會發言權、參與協商及提出法案,並深入探討立委在審查委員會上的發言內容是否受到政黨、選區、個人及國會制度等因素的影響。
本研究以「公共事務類」法案-「公共電視法」與「國防法」進行個案分析,經過實際檢證,研究結果有三:第一,立法委員的行為並非只受單一因素影響,而是許多因素相互競逐;第二,法案的發動機關不同,會衍生法案通過與否的變數;第三,立委的立法行為未必符合影響因素的行為假設。
Abstract
“Standing committees” is the most important investigating mechanism in the Legislative Yuan. Legislators are in charge of the legislation, and they are responsible for the whole fellow in the country. The legislators’ behaviors may directly or indirectly affect the legislative process and outcomes. Of all the legislators’ behaviors, the investigation of bills in the standing committees is the most significant one. Therefore, the main purpose of this thesis focuses on legislator’s behavior of investigating bills in the standing committees.
It includes signature、 speaking、retain for speaking in the chamber、negotiating and addressed bills. And I will probe into the content of legislator’s speaking in the standing committees. According to the “representative theory”, members will represent that affect them the most.
I will take “public affair bill”-“The law of PTS” and “The law of national defense” for case study analysis. By empirical examination, it could be three results: firstly, not only legislator’s behavior affected by single factor but also other factors;secondly, it may create variable of the bill past or not by the different mechanism;Furthermore, Legislative Yuan lacked of professionalism but pervaded the opportunism.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 國家發展研究
- ISSN
- 1017-1355
- 卷期
- 10卷1期
- 出版
- 2010年12月
- 頁碼
- 53–96
- 編號
- NTUEJ00002293
同期目錄
- 國家與性別:台灣照顧政策性別化探析姜貞吟(Chen-Yin Chiang)・頁 1–34
- 論德國國際私法上穆斯林 「多重婚」之問題劉文超(Wen-Chao Liu)・頁 35–52
- 從法案到法律—立委立法行為之實證分析:「公共事務類」法案之個案分析陳昌宏(Chang-Hung Chen)・頁 53–96
- 論客家與現代中國革命之關係─以太平天國和辛亥革命為例顧朋(Manouchehr Ghorbani-Koshkaki)・頁 97–158
- 論孫中山與南洋檳榔嶼客家華僑黃玫瑄(Mei-Hsuan Huang)・頁 159–203