臺大學術期刊資料庫NTU Journal Database

歷史與人生─尼采於《不合時宜之觀察》 對歷史方法論與目的論之批判

Why Resemblance is Not a Relation? -Trope Ontology in a Conceptualist Guise

孫雲平(Yun-Ping Sun)

卷期
45期
出版
2013年03月
頁碼
5–38
編號
NTUEJ00002439
全文限校內本刊全文只能在臺大校內網路閱讀。

你目前的連線不在校內範圍,所以無法開啟全文。書目與摘要不受限制;回到校內網路後重新整理本頁,全文就會直接顯示。

摘要

本文嘗試釐清尼采於〈歷史對人生之利弊〉一文中對於歷史的觀點以及
其對歷史跟人生關係的主張。其中主要說明尼采於本篇論文如何批判「歷史」
目的論及歷史書寫的方法論:尼采認為人類活動以及歷史本身沒有終極目
的、歷史書寫不可能達至客觀的要求。換言之,追求客觀性目標的歷史書寫
將因為作為純粹的理論性知識而成為人類生活與行動的阻礙、使人類的生命
萎縮與僵化。歷史知識以及記憶在尼采的眼中,成為人類生命之自主性創造
與實踐的絆腳石。藉此尼采展示人類個體的生命特徵:生命不僅不可能永恆
不朽、甚至並非實體性的存在、同時不必然是合乎理性、道德的與正義的。
生命是必朽的、是一個不斷流變的、及難以理性掌握的現象。通過對歷史與
歷史書寫態度的分析,尼采強調生命必須不斷地透過自主的抉擇、行動與實
踐來自我實現與自我超越。

Abstract

This paper tries to elucidate what Nietzsche’s view of history and his
thesis about the relationship between history and life would be in his essay
On the Advantages and Disadvantages of History for the Life. It is above all
to explain how Nietzsche criticizes the teleology of history and the
methodology of historiography in this article: Nietzsche claims that there
would be no ultimate destination of human activities and the history itself,
and that historical writing could not fulfill the objective standard. In another
words, the historical writing which runs after the goal of objectivity would,
as purely theoretical knowledge, become an obstacle of human life and
action, and would then wither and ossify the human life. Historical
knowledge and memory would be, in the sight of Nietzsche, a stone of
stumbling to autonomous creativity and practice of human life. By this
Nietzsche demonstrates the characteristics of human individual life: Neither
can life be eternal and immortal, nor would it even be a substantial being; at
the same time, it would not necessarily be rational, moral and just. Life ismortal and is a perpetually changing and unfathomable phenomenon. By
analyzing the attitude toward history and historical writing, Nietzsche lays
the emphasis that life would have to realize itself and surpass itself by the
autonomous determination, action and practice.

關鍵詞

程式與 AI 助手可以改用資料介面(JSON、MCP),查詢比讀頁面快。給程式與 AI 代理的存取說明