臺大學術期刊資料庫NTU Journal Database

朱熹批判「觀過知仁」與「知覺為仁」之 探討─對比於程明道與謝上蔡的詮釋進路

Zhu Xi’s Critique of the Hu Xiang Scholars’ Understanding of “Humaneness”: An Analysis of How Zhu Xi’s View Differs from Hsieh Liang-Tso’s as Contrasted with Cheng Hao’s Interpretation

沈享民(Hsiang-Min Shen)

卷期
45期
出版
2013年03月
頁碼
39–60
編號
NTUEJ00002440
全文限校內本刊全文只能在臺大校內網路閱讀。

你目前的連線不在校內範圍,所以無法開啟全文。書目與摘要不受限制;回到校內網路後重新整理本頁,全文就會直接顯示。

摘要

本文研究朱熹與湖湘學者的兩個辯論:「觀過知仁」與「知覺為仁」,並
論證朱熹對謝良佐與湖湘諸學者的義理之理解並非無據。首先,本文檢視由
朱熹書信與相關文獻所保存下來的論辯內容,並討論朱熹之所以反對湖湘學
者以「知覺」定義「仁」的理據。朱熹認為仁不是一種高妙玄虛的知覺,仁
雖不是知覺本身,但有仁德的人必有知覺。依朱熹,仁專指心之德,即心靈
的卓越品質;有仁德的人以義理為知覺內容,而非只是知覺;知覺本身屬於
智而不是仁。進一步,本文論證:湖湘學者之所以認定知覺為仁,其理由在
於繼受了謝良佐所表述「仁」的內涵,後者遺落了程顥彰顯仁的生動明澈所
善用的類比或譬喻;相對地,謝良佐的表述幾乎接近以定義的方式呈現。是
以,即便是朱熹錯解了湖湘學者的義理,在表述方式上,其實事出有因。

Abstract

This paper focuses on two famous debates concerning “humaneness”
between Zhu Xi and the Hu Xiang scholars. Based on the survey of literature,
this paper tries to justify, at least partly, what Zhu Xi comprehends about the
philosophical position of Hu Xiang School.
According to Zhu Xi’s philosophy, “humaneness” specifically labels the
complete virtue of mind which exemplifies excellent qualities. On the one
hand, Zhu Xi objects to the claim of those Hu Xiang scholars that
“humaneness” can be defined as “vivid perception”; on the other hand, he
argued that perception is by nature attributed to the intellectual virtue,
although the humane person certainly possesses the competence of
perception. As a matter of fact, the key point of the two debates between Zhu
Xi and the Hu Xiang scholars is how to treat Hsieh Liang-Tso’s
interpretation of humaneness.Furthermore, this paper argues that Cheng Hao, Hsieh’s teacher,
illustrated distinctively the concept of humaneness in his own analogical or
metaphorical way, but Hsieh’s formulation of it is akin to definition of a
certain kind. This missed link or the rhetorical nuance is the reason why the
Hu Xiang scholars follow Hsieh’s approach to humaneness and Zhu Xi has
to argue against their ideas of humaneness

關鍵詞

程式與 AI 助手可以改用資料介面(JSON、MCP),查詢比讀頁面快。給程式與 AI 代理的存取說明