從西方的二值真理觀到中西合璧的三值真理觀:一個三值「檢證邏輯」與「檢證理論」之創立
From the Western 2-valued Logic to a Combined Eastern and Western 3-valued Logic-the Construction of a 3-valued Confirmation Logic & Confirmation Theory
- 卷期
- 13期
- 出版
- 1990年01月
- 頁碼
- 025–050
- 編號
- NTUEJ00002629
Abstract
In this paper we first point out that there are six difficulties facing the 2-valued classical logic, which is exclusively a Western production. The six difficulties are: (1)Aristotelian problem of future contingents, (2)the liar paradox, (3)the controversy between Russell's theory of definite descriptions and Strawson's theory of presupposition, (4)Goodman's problem of indoor ornithology, (5)C. I. Lewis' paradoxes of implication, and (6)the paradoxes of confirmation.
Then, we try to solve the paradoxes of confirmation by constructing a 3-valued quantificational logic called "confirmation logic", which is shown to be semantically complete. Employing the newly constructed 3-valued confirmation logic we build up a 3-valued confirmation theory which solves the paradoxes of confirmation. Furthermore the confirmation logic turns out to be able to solve the other five difficulties facing the 2-valued classical logic. So, maybe it is time for us to have a change of logic.