臺大學術期刊資料庫NTU Journal Database

Vico or Spinoza: An Other Way of Looking at Theory, circa 1983

Yoshiaki Mihara

Graduate School of Language and Society, Hitotsubashi University, Japan

類型
特別企劃:研究論文
卷期
40期
出版
2018年12月
頁碼
007–036
編號
NTUEJ00000285
全文限校內本刊全文只能在臺大校內網路閱讀。

你目前的連線不在校內範圍,所以無法開啟全文。書目與摘要不受限制;回到校內網路後重新整理本頁,全文就會直接顯示。

摘要

This is an anachronistic attempt to revisit “Theory in the 1980s” by casting light from an Other angle, namely, two anti-Cartesian critical tours de force—Vichian criticism and Spinozist critique—heuristically corresponding to Edward W. Said’s “secular criticism” and Paul de Man’s “deconstructive critique,” respectively. Said’s article “Secular Criticism” and de Man’s Messenger Lectures, both appearing in 1983, are closely analyzed in light of topics, patent or latent, including “epistemology of error”; “truth-as-trope and the-True-as-occurrence”; “the literal and figural body”; “humanized and dehumanized conatus”; “Humanistic and dehumanized philology”; “secularism and worldliness”; “oppositional criticism and immanent critique”; and “Ethics-as-ethology.” The essay’s end is emphatically not to “map”— let alone “define”—the entire discursive formation tentatively called “Theory in the 1980s,” but, rather, to essayistically open up the field of speculation beyond the spatio-temporal confines of individual oppositions or conflicts that informed those particular discourses. In the end, a possibility of reading the conjunction “or” in the title, “Vico or Spinoza,” as otherwise than oppositional, will be suggested in the form of a post-scriptum supplement.

Abstract

This is an anachronistic attempt to revisit “Theory in the 1980s” by casting light from an Other angle, namely, two anti-Cartesian critical tours de force—Vichian criticism and Spinozist critique—heuristically corresponding to Edward W. Said’s “secular criticism” and Paul de Man’s “deconstructive critique,” respectively. Said’s article “Secular Criticism” and de Man’s Messenger Lectures, both appearing in 1983, are closely analyzed in light of topics, patent or latent, including “epistemology of error”; “truth-as-trope and the-True-as-occurrence”; “the literal and figural body”; “humanized and dehumanized conatus”; “Humanistic and dehumanized philology”; “secularism and worldliness”; “oppositional criticism and immanent critique”; and “Ethics-as-ethology.” The essay’s end is emphatically not to “map”— let alone “define”—the entire discursive formation tentatively called “Theory in the 1980s,” but, rather, to essayistically open up the field of speculation beyond the spatio-temporal confines of individual oppositions or conflicts that informed those particular discourses. In the end, a possibility of reading the conjunction “or” in the title, “Vico or Spinoza,” as otherwise than oppositional, will be suggested in the form of a post-scriptum supplement.

關鍵詞

程式與 AI 助手可以改用資料介面(JSON、MCP),查詢比讀頁面快。給程式與 AI 代理的存取說明