馴夫記:解讀《結局好萬事好》中的心理劇
The Taming of the Prodigal Husband: All’s Well That Ends Well as a Psychological Drama
國立臺灣大學外國語文學系 (Department of Foreign Languages and Literatures National Taiwan University)
- 類型
- 論文
- 卷期
- 38期
- 出版
- 2017年12月
- 頁碼
- 001–026
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000300
你目前的連線不在校內範圍,所以無法開啟全文。書目與摘要不受限制;回到校內網路後重新整理本頁,全文就會直接顯示。
摘要
《結局好萬事好》(又譯為《終成眷屬》)是莎士比亞初於倫敦劇壇嶄露頭角 時期的作品,寫成於一五九零年代中期。本劇歷來並不受青睞:莎翁當代的觀眾 不甚喜愛;演出率始終偏低;批評家鮮少給予好評。劇本描述一位棄婦忍辱完成 一連串不可思議的艱鉅任務,終於挽回郎心。本劇原屬喜劇類,後世多將其歸類 為「問題劇」,顯示它的劇型或核心議題難以清楚劃分為喜或悲。劇名出自於英 文俗諺「結局好萬事好」,意謂凡事若能獲得好的結局,相形之下過程的波折實 在微不足道;而「終成眷屬」的意譯則適切點出這段姻緣歷經百折千磨方能成就。 唯其如此,劇終的曖昧陰鬱特別令人困惑不安,也是歷代學者著墨的焦點,四百 多年以來成為莎劇研究裡的一樁公案。本劇究竟是莎翁的瑕疵作品,抑或是作家 別有用心,寓意於弦外呢?
Abstract
All’s Well That Ends Well, a play produced when Shakespeare emerged as London’s leading playwright in the mid-1590s, seems to be nobody’s favorite: it was not popu- lar with its first audience, it is rarely acted, and it has seldom received much praise from critics. The play is about an abandoned wife who accomplishes a series of seemingly impossible tasks in order to regain her prodigal husband. Though original- ly classified as a comedy, the play is now considered one of Shakespeare’s problem plays, so codified because they cannot be neatly classified as either tragedy or come- dy. The title of this play is the proverb “all’s well that ends well,” which means the process does not really matter as long as the outcome is good. The ending of the play, however, has been a focus of critical discontent and has bothered its audience/readers for four centuries. Is this disturbing ending an intended effect or simply a failed at- tempt of the Bard? I will answer this question in the following paper. Drawing on the theories of psychoanalysis, particularly the object-relations of Melanie Klein (1882-1960), this essay aims to map out that space where a late adolescent is wres- tling his way to adulthood and thereby spell out his resistance to marrying the hero- ine. I propose that this is a key to understanding the play and to explaining its luke- warm reception. The main problem of this play, I shall argue, rests on the hero’s mental pain or growing pain of not living in an ideal world. His final recognition that love itself is not simply a phantasy but a matter of complex adjustments marks the beginning of his real, adult journey. To read All’s Well as a rich inner phantasy life of Bertram, I shall look at the psychological processes of the hero and how they are put into the context of crucial experiences of his story and relationships.