臺大學術期刊資料庫NTU Journal Database

關係企業債權人保護之發展趨勢:以揭穿公司面紗為核心

Piercing the Corporate Veil in Corporate Groups

洪秀芬(Shiu-Feng Hung);朱德芳(Te-Fang Chu)

東吳大學法學院法律系

類型
論著
卷期
43卷3期
出版
2014年09月
頁碼
641–718
編號
NTUEJ00003009
僅書目本篇只提供書目資料,資料庫沒有電子全文。

需要全文時,可以向出版單位洽詢,聯絡方式見期刊資訊。

摘要

為保護公司債權人,我國公司法關係企業專章於第369-4條規定,控制公司使從屬公司為不合營業常規或其他不利益經營時,控制公司若不補償,從屬公司可請求損害賠償,此一請求權亦可由從屬公司之債權人代位行使。這類案件於我國司法實務中卻極為罕見,從屬公司債權人較常見以「揭穿公司面紗原則」,要求控制公司對從屬公司之債務負責。過去,實務上對於我國是否承認揭穿公司面紗原則見解分歧,在各方呼籲下,公司法於2013年1月30日修正時新增第154條第2項,加入揭穿公司面紗條款。新法雖提供揭穿公司面紗的法律依據,但應如何適用,仍有頗多疑義,特別是關係企業適用時,是否因其組織與運作上的特點,而應有不同的考量,值得進一步探究。我國制定關係企業專章時,參考德國立法例,如今新法揭穿公司面紗借鏡自美國,故本文將介紹德、美兩國之相關法規與實務見解,並評析我國因雷曼兄弟集團破產後,原告主張揭穿公司面紗,要求雷曼集團之母公司或其他子公司應負賠償責任之相關案件。最後,本文提出修法建議。

Abstract

To protect corporate creditors in corporate groups, Article 369-4 of Taiwan Company Law provides that when a controlling company has caused its subsidiary to conduct any business contrary to normal business practice and failed to pay an appropriate compensation, such controlling company shall be liable for the subsidiary's damage; creditor of the subsidiary may claim damages for the company. However, in practice such suits have been extremely rare. Instead, creditors of the subsidiary often argue the doctrine of piercing the corporate veil and demand the controlling company to pay for the debt of the subsidiary. Before the Company Law provides the piercing the corporate veil in its 2012 amendment, courts' opinions were divided on this matter. Along with the recent amendment, new issues require attention. By analyzing relevant laws and cases in Germany and the United States, this paper aims to provide suggestions on how the new laws apply, especially in the context of corporate groups.

關鍵詞

程式與 AI 助手可以改用資料介面(JSON、MCP),查詢比讀頁面快。給程式與 AI 代理的存取說明