臺大學術期刊資料庫NTU Journal Database

奧罕•帕慕克《黑色之書》中的重複與學習之旅

Repetition and Apprenticeship in Orhan Pamuk’s The Black Book

陳佩筠(Pei-yun Chen)

淡江大學英文學系 (Department of English, Tamkang University)

類型
論文
卷期
37期
出版
2017年06月
頁碼
001–022
編號
NTUEJ00000304
全文限校內本刊全文只能在臺大校內網路閱讀。

你目前的連線不在校內範圍,所以無法開啟全文。書目與摘要不受限制;回到校內網路後重新整理本頁,全文就會直接顯示。

摘要

奧罕‧帕慕克的《黑色之書》充滿神秘離奇又相互矛盾的特點,常被歸類為
後現代小說。然而不同於大部分後現代小說強調自我認識以及意義追尋終究是不
可得的,本書主角的偵探之旅並非以全然失敗作結。書中主角蓋立普在整座伊斯
坦堡四處尋找人間蒸發的妻子與堂兄時,重讀了堂兄席拉從前所寫的報紙專欄,
並在故事最後不厭其煩地重述古老的故事。正是此重讀與重述故事的過程使他逐
漸變成另一個人,也正是由於他的流變,他才能找到做他自己的可能性。本文援
引德勒茲對於「重複」以及「學徒鍛鍊」等概念的論述提出以下論點:《黑色之
書》中出現的這些「重複」(重讀、重述、重寫、雙生等)並非單純作為後現代
小說中用以擾亂讀者理性思緒或創造幻覺效果的寫作策略,而是一條看不見的
線,串聯起一段蓋立普的學習之旅。德勒茲所論的「重複」必須從「關係」的角
度理解之,而《黑色之書》具體展示出重複的重要意涵,亦即任何一次重複都必
然包含不同個體之間的關係。在蓋立普對於席拉亦步亦趨的重複過程中,他自身
也發生變化,而他每一個變化都實現了某種關係,也就是認識的主體與被認識的
個體之間的關係。

Abstract

Written in the form of a quest novel with mysterious and paradoxical traits, The
Black Book is widely categorized as “postmodern fiction.” However, unlike most
postmodern novels which thwart every attempt to search for meaning and self-knowledge,
The Black Book does not dismiss the protagonist’s detection as a total failure. In the
search for his disappeared wife and cousin Celal, Galip, the protagonist, rereads the
old columns and at the end of the story he retells the ancient tales. In his rereading and
retelling of the story he becomes someone else, and in his becoming someone else he
finds a way to be himself. Taking Gilles Deleuze’s notions of repetition and apprenticeship,
in this paper I argue that repetition in this story is not simply a postmodern
device to confuse readers or to create illusionary effects, but a thread weaving Galip’s
apprenticeship, that is, a continuous process of learning. In Deleuze’s sense, repetition
must be understood in terms of relation, and The Black Book illustrates exactly how
repetition signifies relations between individuals. In repeating Celal’s every step,
Galip transforms and changes himself, and each change actualizes a relation between
the knowing subject and the known individual.

關鍵詞

程式與 AI 助手可以改用資料介面(JSON、MCP),查詢比讀頁面快。給程式與 AI 代理的存取說明