重新檢視未遂犯的可罰基礎與著手時點:以客觀未遂理論及客觀犯行的實質化為中心
Criminal Attempt Reviewed: On the Basis of Objective Attempt Theory and Materialization of Punishable Action
國立政治大學法學院
- 類型
- 論著
- 卷期
- 40卷4期
- 出版
- 2011年12月
- 頁碼
- 2397–2473
- 編號
- NTUEJ00003076
需要全文時,可以向出版單位洽詢,聯絡方式見期刊資訊。
摘要
本文探討刑法修正後,未遂犯的可罰理由(未遂理論)與著手時點的判斷方法,有別於通說採用印象理論,筆者主張客觀未遂理論,從而區別出行為時點的危險,以及「行為後、流程終結前」的中間危險狀態,只有達到中間危險狀態才能認定未遂犯;基此,判斷未遂刑責的著手時點,可以類型化為三種形態,筆者並發展出三階段的著手判斷流程。
Abstract
This article explores the penal reasons of criminal attempts and the criterion to establish criminal attempts after the legislative amendment of Criminal Code in 2005. Other than the common thesis which stands for the theory of impression (Eindruckstheorie), the author adopts the theory of objective endangerment, and distinguishes ”danger ex ante” from ”danger in transition.” The author argues that merely the latter one can justify the punishment of criminal attempt. Lastly, a three-level model is proposed to examine whether a criminal attempt is committed.