French Theories of Administrative Discretion before World War Ⅱ: Focus on the Function of Public Service and the Scope of Judicial Control
法國戰前行政裁量理論:以行政任務與司法審查之範圍爲中心
台大法研所博士畢
- Section
- contents
- Issue
- Vol. 36, No. 4
- Published
- 2007-12
- Pages
- 157–256
- Record ID
- NTUEJ00003212
To obtain the full text, contact the publisher. See About the journal.
Abstract (Chinese)
本文建議以不法交易為主,重新設計債務清理法之補足規定,並重思民法強制聲請宣告破產之賠償規定有無存在之必要,俾使我國在董監對債權人責任之論述上有其一貫之條理。
Abstract
In the discharge of their missions, Government agencies are allowed to exercise discretionary power to a certain degree in reply to peculiar circumstances in any given case, such as the time, location, or nature of the case to boost efficiency. Such discretion, however, does not provide an absolute safe harbor for all agency actions, as part of which, under certain circumstances, are still subject to judicial scrutiny. The split of authority between the lawfulness and the appropriateness test as applied in complaint against improper exercise of discretion may affect one's redressability, prompting a heated debate in the pre-war era among French academia. Despite the legitimacy of professor M. Hauriou's theory on administrative morality, once upheld by the Conseil d'Etat in pre-war France, gradually eroded away in the postwar era, the principles thus enshrined may nevertheless provide insightful guidance on rethinking the correlation between state power and the existence of government agencies. The modifier ”before WWII” in the heading shall not be understood to qualify this note as a reservoir of antecedent documents from previous years; the purpose of this note, rather, is to provide a sketch of significant features on administrative discretion in French administration theory, and, from this comparative perspective, to seek further to invite more discussions in the development of a deeper appreciation of the administrative law.