艾蜜莉‧狄菫蓀—以蘇格拉底批判精神探究愛默生先驗論的哲學詩人
Paternal Presence/Absence, Manliness, and Subversion:
國立中山大學外文博士(Ph.D., Department of Foreign Languages and Literature, National Sun Yat-sen University)
- 類型
- 一般論文
- 卷期
- 32期
- 出版
- 2014年12月
- 頁碼
- 001–036
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000325
你目前的連線不在校內範圍,所以無法開啟全文。書目與摘要不受限制;回到校內網路後重新整理本頁,全文就會直接顯示。
摘要
艾蜜莉‧狄菫蓀經常掙扎在確知與不知之間,她肯定「內心懷疑態度論」,
因為此論點能夠幫助她檢視觀點和原理。如同她在詩作1438 中所示,為了避免
「確定性耗竭」(“Certainty be sere”),她追求卻又「拒絕認定真理」(“then retards
the truth”)。無論是她的生活或者作品都對權威式的觀點抱持懷疑的態度。她不
輕率否認或接受任何既定的知識和意見,不允許任何思想理論限制她的思考。
她不斷地實驗、從不同的角度檢視內在心靈與自然世界,並與之對話,因此,
在著作中呈現永無止境的知識探究與自我探索的過程。特別喜愛能激發思維和想
像力,或顛覆知識書籍的她,為拉爾夫‧沃爾多‧愛默生(Ralph Waldo Emerson)
的先驗哲學所激勵,她研究愛默生的哲學,卻不為其論點所限。在先驗論的自
由主義鼓舞下,狄菫蓀儘管有類似愛默生先驗論的觀察與體驗,卻不讓她的思
考探索局限在先驗哲學框架中,而是保持自己個體性、獨立性、懷疑態度和實
驗性的特質,充分發揮蘇格拉底(Socrates)和愛默生所提倡不墨守成規之「美
國學者」(“American Scholar”)精神。她揭示了先驗論中值得商榷的論點,並
跳脫先驗認知的思維,透過多方面探索與實驗程序,表達多樣化或是前後矛盾、
衝突的想法,並保留不確定與互相對立的思辨。於是,她的詩作呈現了如同弗
朗索瓦‧李歐塔(Jean-François Lyotard)所歸納的一種能創造出「後現代超凡」
的特質。讀者若是依照傑德‧戴普曼(Jed Deppman)的建議,與狄堇蓀一同思
索探討愛默生先驗論的精髓與本質,即使沒有得到肯定的真理認知,將有機會
與愛默生的思想對話,進而衍生出自己獨到的見解與智慧。
(curiosity)和「詭譎性」(curiousness),以爬梳其筆下女主角與男性的關係。
勃朗特筆下的物品經常深具神秘感,脫離原有的環境並且被收藏在密閉空間
中,因而這些物品帶著一種無以名狀的詭譎性,其中尤以女性角色所收藏的紀
念品為最。勃朗特所描述的男女關係絕大部分以偶像崇拜為原型,因而這些女
性崇拜者所蒐集的、與她們情人/偶像相關的紀念品所夾帶的詭譎性正反映了
她們充滿矛盾的崇拜情結。另一方面,在勃朗特的敘述中,對於男性來說女性
角色也經常被視為奇異的物品,引起他們觀視與收藏的慾望。本文首先探討勃
朗特女性角色所收集的紀念品,尤其是由頭髮或花朵製成的紀念品,以闡明這
些女性角色的偶像崇拜情結中所包含的矛盾、否認、以及自我否定。以此為出
發點,本文接著探討在男性眼中,女性本身亦帶著詭譎性,彷彿值得收藏的逸
品般引起他們的好奇心,吸引其視覺上及觸覺上的佔有慾望。這樣的詭譎性使
得女性在吸引男性視線的同時能夠避開男性觀視的穿透/辨析能力,使得觀視
/被觀視的機制得以永恆運作。在這樣的視覺機制裡,勃朗特的女性角色同時
是好奇的收藏者與詭譎的收藏品,而正是在這樣的機制下,她們與其情人的矛
盾關係方能被彰顯。
Abstract
Emily Dickinson, who “knows – and does not know,” deems “skepticism of the
Heart” sweet for it inspiringly examines views and axioms, leading to constant inquiry
and self-exploration in her writings. As suggested in poem 1438, she exerts a heart as
well as mind which invites but “then retards the truth” lest “Certainty be sere.” Both
her life and writings demonstrate an inclination to quesion dominant perspectives,
constantly experiment, search, and enter into dialogue with her own self and the
world, disallowing “an Axiom” the “Opportunity” to confine her thinking and composition.
Accordingly, even though manifesting the potentiality of books to inspire her
thinking and imagination, Dickinson, with the spirit of Socrates as well as Ralph
Waldo Emerson in his “American Scholar,” intends to be “Man thinking” and write
her own books in poetry. With stimulation from Transcendentalist liberalism and a
Socratic spirit urging critical thinking, Dickinson explores in various directions and
observes experience from diverse perspectives and through various lenses. Despite her
observations similar to those of Transcendentalists, Dickinson is not “subdued” by her
“instruments” of inspiration. Maintaining her individuality, extreme independence,
“Sweet skepticism of the Heart,” and the essence of “Experiment” and “Wonder” in
thinking, she brings the spirit of Socrates and the nonconformist American scholar
into full play so as not to be limited to the thinking orbit of Emersonian Transcendentalism.
Instead, she reveals its controversial aspects—what is questionable or not absolutely true—encouraging a reinvestigation into Emerson’s philosophy. Dickinson
presents the multifarious aspects of the inner as well as natural world, revealing her
disinheritance from transcendental knowledge, which David Porter regards as the
Dickinson “mark of modernism” while Jed Deppman views such disinheritance along
with her constant questioning of authority as postmodern in Trying to Think with
Emily Dickinson. Writings created by Dickinson as a skeptical philosopher poet who
constantly interrogates without easily accepting or rejecting learned philosophies indeed
can be understood as postmodern especially as she often leaves indeterminacy
indeterminate, the irreconcilable irreconcilable, and composes not within pre-established
rules but through a program of constant exploration/experimentation similar to that
which Jean-François Lyotard attributes to the creation of a postmodern sublime. If
readers try to think with Dickinson as Deppman suggests and explore the essence of
Emersonian Transcendentalism with her, they will have the chance to awaken to the
difference between the conceptual but superficial understanding and the visceral/profound
realization of Emerson’s philosophy as well as the inner and natural worlds. They may
thereby develop their personal comprehension of the philosophy and wisdom.