By Definition Ignored?: Indigenous Peoples’ Fishing Rights in The WTO Fisheries Subsidies Agreement 2022
Professor of international economic law at Otaru University of Commerce (Japan).
摘要
Inclusive trade is a pressing need for the future world trading system. Indigenous peoples are among the most vulnerable and marginalized groups in many countries, either developed or developing countries, throughout their entanglement with globalization and require public support to maintain their traditions as well as economic life. For these reasons, many World Trade Organization (hereinafter “WTO”) member states provide fisheries subsidies as a tool for economic development and a proper means for reconciliation with indigenous rights.
However, fisheries subsidies have been subject to greater scrutiny, and the need for further international regulation is widely recognized from the perspective of sustainable development. Against this background, this study examines the impact of the WTO Agreement on Fisheries Subsidies (hereinafter “FSA”) 2022 to cast light on potential legal impacts that the current FSA 2022 could have on indigenous communities, especially those who depend on fishing for their subsistence.
We start with a brief description of the factual background of the difficulties that many indigenous peoples are facing, and then summarize indigenous peoples’ rights to fishing in the relevant fields of international law (Section II). Next, we find legal uncertainties in the jurisdictional part of the FSA 2022, especially in its scope and definition clauses (Section III.A). We identify several systemic concerns that may emerge from such uncertainties (Section III.B) and propose that such concerns should be addressed in the course of the ongoing negotiations for the comprehensive disciplines, and that inserting an exception clause for the indigenous peoples’ rights is an option (Section IV).
Abstract
Inclusive trade is a pressing need for the future world trading system. Indigenous peoples are among the most vulnerable and marginalized groups in many countries, either developed or developing countries, throughout their entanglement with globalization and require public support to maintain their traditions as well as economic life. For these reasons, many World Trade Organization (hereinafter “WTO”) member states provide fisheries subsidies as a tool for economic development and a proper means for reconciliation with indigenous rights.
However, fisheries subsidies have been subject to greater scrutiny, and the need for further international regulation is widely recognized from the perspective of sustainable development. Against this background, this study examines the impact of the WTO Agreement on Fisheries Subsidies (hereinafter “FSA”) 2022 to cast light on potential legal impacts that the current FSA 2022 could have on indigenous communities, especially those who depend on fishing for their subsistence.
We start with a brief description of the factual background of the difficulties that many indigenous peoples are facing, and then summarize indigenous peoples’ rights to fishing in the relevant fields of international law (Section II). Next, we find legal uncertainties in the jurisdictional part of the FSA 2022, especially in its scope and definition clauses (Section III.A). We identify several systemic concerns that may emerge from such uncertainties (Section III.B) and propose that such concerns should be addressed in the course of the ongoing negotiations for the comprehensive disciplines, and that inserting an exception clause for the indigenous peoples’ rights is an option (Section IV).
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- Asian Journal of WTO & International Health Law and policy
- ISSN
- 1819-5164
- 卷期
- 19卷1期
- 出版
- 2024年03月
- 頁碼
- 143–164
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000035
同期目錄
- The Fisheries Subsidies Agreement— A Landmark Accord for Ocean SustainabilityChang-fa Lo・頁 1–2
- Potential Welfare Impact of Fishery Subsidy RemovalTaleb Awad Warrad・頁 3–25
- Sustainable Seas? Assessing Commitments and Implications of the WTO Fisheries Subsidies AgreementJulien Chaisse, Debashis Chakraborty & Animesh Kumar・頁 27–65
- Subsidies Contributing to Overcapacity and Overfishing: The Challenges in Completing the Third Pillar of the WTO Fisheries AgreementJames J. Nedumpara & Priyansha Hajela・頁 67–101
- Converge or Diverge? The New Fisheries Subsidies Agreement and the SCM AgreementJaemin Lee・頁 103–142
- By Definition Ignored?: Indigenous Peoples’ Fishing Rights in The WTO Fisheries Subsidies Agreement 2022Tomohiko Kobayashi・頁 143–164
- Implementation of Vietnam’s Commitments on Fisheries Subsidies in its FTAs and Recommendations for Those Under the WTO Agreement on Fisheries SubsidiesNguyen Ngoc Ha & Vu Kim Ngan・頁 165–187
- International Economic Law in a Multi-Polar World Without Effective UN and WTO Constitutional ConstraintsErnst Ulrich Petersmann・頁 189–229
- Financial Inclusion as a Public Policy Issue in the Global Digital EconomyRolf H. Weber・頁 231–252