《阿新》劇中有關中國族群與美國兩性的議題
American Gender Issues and Chinese Ethnicity in Ah Sin
國立高雄大學西洋語文學系(Department of Western Languages and Literature, National University of Kaohsiung)
- 類型
- 論文
- 卷期
- 24期
- 出版
- 2010年12月
- 頁碼
- 107–132
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000376
你目前的連線不在校內範圍,所以無法開啟全文。書目與摘要不受限制;回到校內網路後重新整理本頁,全文就會直接顯示。
摘要
馬克吐溫與布列特哈特合著的《阿新》一劇,背景設於淘金潮時期的美國加
州,該區匯聚各種不同的文化與性別觀念。雖然十九世紀美國的東方論述常將東
方人邊緣化和女性化,《阿新》一劇卻以中國人為主角。本文論證:該劇不僅破
除固有的東方人刻板形象,更藉由描寫白人女性與中國僕人的關係,闡述當代性
別議題與對中國人種族歧視的關聯。此劇探討美國西部新興的意識觀念,強調家
務管理有助於穩定國家根基,藉此肯定白人女性與中國僕人對美國社會的貢獻。
劇中對中國勞工與白人女性以平行方式描寫: 儘管中國角色受到歧視而被女性
化,但最終仍回復其「男子氣魄」,正如女主角在劇終糾正傳統對弱女子的觀念。
綜言之,《阿新》一劇所呈現的美國白人女性與中國僕人角色,同時為當時的弱
勢女性與弱勢族群發出不平之鳴,質疑十九世紀美國的東方論述中視西方陽剛而
東方陰柔的錯誤對比。
Abstract
Ah Sin, a collaboration of Mark Twain and Bret Harte, is set in the multicultural frontier
of gold rush California, where several cultural and gender ideologies met.
Whereas nineteenth-century American Orientalism tended to marginalize and feminize
the Orient, Ah Sin figures the Chinese as the central character. This article
argues that, in addition to the disruption of Oriental stereotypes, the play’s portrayal
of white females in relation to a Chinese servant points toward contemporary gender
issues in relation to racism against the Chinese. By exploring the emerging frontier
ideologies that emphasized the importance of domestic work and house management
in maintaining the stability of the nation, the play acknowledges the contributions of
Chinese servants and white women to American society. Much as the feminized
Chinese character restores his “manhood” notwithstanding the sexist stereotypes of
the Chinese as effeminate, the heroine undermines the stereotyped notions about frail
womanhood. The play reflects on the parallels in the development of each group’s
struggles. As such, Ah Sin challenges many levels of racist and gendered assumptions
prevalent in the 19th century American Orientalism by way of dismantling the
false binary between the masculine West and the feminine East.