在田野中找歷史: 三十年來的中國華南社會史研究與人類學
Doing History in the Field: Historical and Anthropological Studies of Southern China over the Last Three Decades
中央研究院歷史語言研究所,助研究員
摘要
近年來中國明清史研究的重要發展之一是強調從基層社會出發、重視田野實察與地方
文獻的地方社會史研究。這樣的研究取向可以追溯到八零年代受西方社會科學訓練的學者與
中國本地的歷史學者從華南開始的合作,也因此這樣的研究取向常被標誌為「華南學派」或
「歷史人類學」。這些華南社會的研究者,與同時期的社會科學研究者一樣,同樣面臨如何
在時間的向度底下處理社會結構的問題;所不同的是華南研究者所研究的對象是受久遠歷史
影響更深刻、也與國家制度有更長久之互動經驗的基層社會。本文梳理三十年來從華南研究
出發之明清社會史研究所討論的核心議題,包括基層社會結構的歷史過程,特別是制度與禮
儀的地方實踐在其中扮演的角色。並與同時期西方人類學界對於歷史過程、歷史心性與歷史
書寫的討論相比較。
Abstract
One of the most remarkable achievements of studies of late imperial
China in recent years has been studies of local society that emphasize the
bottom-up view and the use of sources from fieldwork and local documents.
This approach can be traced back to the 80’s when social scientists trained by
western academics cooperated with Chinese historians to study southern
China, an approach usually labeled the “Southern China School” or “historical
anthropology.” The central questions that these southern China researchers
and the social scientists of their period faced were the same: how to
understand social structures historically. What was different was that the
southern China researchers were dealing with people more deeply (or least
claiming to be) influenced by their historical past and having a longer history of
interactions with state institutions. This article traces the core issues of this
approach, including the historical process of structuration, and the role of local
practices of rituals performance and state institutions in this process. It also
discusses this approach from the aspects of historical process, historicity and
historiography, which were dealt with by Emiko Ohnuki in her review of
historical anthropology.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 一般論文
- 期刊
- 國立臺灣大學考古人類學刊
- ISSN
- 0077-5843
- 卷期
- 88期
- 出版
- 2018年06月
- 頁碼
- 109–140
- 編號
- NTUEJ00004172
同期目錄
- 專號:與人類學共舞林瑋嬪(Wei-ping Lin)・頁 1–8
- 閾限概念與戲劇研究之初探紀蔚然 (Wei-jan Chi )・頁 9–34
- 時空流轉下的緬華革命樂舞呂心純 (Hsin-Chun Lu)・頁 35–82
- 物、感官與故國:論明遺民董說《非煙香法》許暉林 (Hui-Lin Hsu)・頁 83–108
- 在田野中找歷史: 三十年來的中國華南社會史研究與人類學李仁淵 (Ren-Yuan Li )・頁 109–140
- 特約書評導言林 開 世・頁 183–190
- 《金融經濟、主體性、與新秩序的體現》新書討論會徐進鈺・頁 143–156
- IFRS:回覆徐進鈺教授夏傳位・頁 157–158
- 對徐進鈺教授評論的回應吳 宗 昇・頁 159–162
- 「無常空間」的潛在社會及公共意義蔡 侑 霖・頁 163–166
- 圖示式金融權力運作之外的主體、情感和慾望: 回應徐進鈺教授的評論鄭 瑋 寧・頁 167–172
- 回應與反響黃 應 貴・頁 173–176