撐起雨傘的非常城市:遇見他者的閾限空間
Raising Umbrellas in the Exceptional City: Encounters with the ‘Other’ in Liminal Spaces
國立台灣大學建築與城鄉研究所助理教授(Assistant Professor, Graduate Institute of Building and Planning, National Taiwan University);美國科羅拉多大學地理學博士候選人(PhD Candidate, Department of Geography, University of Colorado at Boulder, USA)
摘要
待客人情從不是香港人形象,然而2014 年遮打運動(又名雨傘運動)過程中,許多港人無論如何要到場「保護學生」的真切實踐,加上各類媒體的大幅重點報導,交織而成的香港人形象是嶄新的、勇敢的、熱情且兼容多元的,好似歡迎任何族裔以粵語大聲高唱海闊天空,一齊撐起雨傘。對照近年全城瀰漫「這城市在死亡」(the city is dying)的低迷,2014 年9 月28 日後「香港人已經不一樣」的論點表現於場內場外各類形式的論述、圖像。本文欲從佔領現場觀察出發,關注其中慇勤待客(hospitality)表現所實踐的時空延展,來探討佔領運動創造的「非常城市」給正常城市社會的啟示。
Abstract
Many of the hundreds of thousands of Hong Kong people who initially
joined the Umbrella Movement had the relatively straightforward goal of
“protecting the students.” Extensive media coverage soon represented protest
participants as passionate, brave, and inclusive, although Hong Kong people
have rarely been noted for their hospitality. In contrast to the pessimistic
narratives of recent years, characterized by phrases such as “the city is dying,”
the Umbrella Movement’s proliferation of citizen-journalism and artistic
production raised the widely-debated possibility that “Hong Kong people have
changed.”
Based on ethnographic observation of the movement from late
September through November 2014 and content analysis of popular and social
media, this article examines the ways in which Hong Kong people articulated
such changes. It pays particular attention to the role of “hospitality” in shaping
discourse and extending the time-space of the Umbrella Movement as social
drama. The urban exceptionality of the Umbrella occupations, we argue,
ultimately requires us to rethink the normativities of the everyday city.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 研究論文
- 期刊
- 國立臺灣大學考古人類學刊
- ISSN
- 0077-5843
- 卷期
- 83期
- 出版
- 2015年12月
- 頁碼
- 25–56
- 編號
- NTUEJ00004209
同期目錄
- 「社會運動中的人類學介入:香港佔中」專號導言趙彥寧(Antonia Chao)・頁 1–4
- 直面香港:群眾運動中的民主訴求與政黨政治項飈(Xiang Biao)・頁 5–24
- 撐起雨傘的非常城市:遇見他者的閾限空間黃舒楣(Shu-mei Huang);伊恩( Ian Rowen)・頁 25–56
- 直面黨國權力:回應項的「雨傘運動」論述葉蔭聰(Iam-chong Ip)・頁 57–74
- 「群眾」和「黨」:中國革命話語進入佔領運動論述陳浩乾(Haoqian Chen)・頁 75–88
- 回應與反響--我們如何敘述當下、進入歷史:兼論人類學的現實角色項飈(Xiang Biao)・頁 89–102
- 《日常生活中的當代宗教:宗教的個人化與關係性存有》特約書評專欄林瑋嬪(Wei-ping Lin)・頁 103–104
- 《日常生活中的當代宗教:宗教的個人化與關係性存有》書評導言蔡英俊(Ying-chun Tsai)・頁 105–108
- 《日常生活中的當代宗教:宗教的個人化與關係性存有》書評蔡彥仁(Yen-zen Tsai)・頁 109–114
- 《日常生活中的當代宗教:宗教的個人化與關係性存有》書評蔡怡佳(Yi-jia Tsai)・頁 115–122
- 回應與反響黃應貴(Ying-kuei Huang)・頁 123–128