直面黨國權力:回應項的「雨傘運動」論述
Directly Facing Party-state Power: A Response to Xiang Biao’s Discourse on Umbrella Movement
香港嶺南大學文化研究系助理教授(Assistant Professor, Department of Cultural Studies, Lingnan University, Hong Kong)
摘要
項飈教授對香港「雨傘運動」的評論,是中國大陸學界一次難得的「民間嘗試」。然而,在項的香港論述裡,幾乎看不到中共在香港民主化裡的角色,以及香港與大陸政治發展分殊的歷史過程。而這一過程正源於中共在1989 年暴力地壓制了黨內外的民主改革訴求及議程,並自1990 年代開始強力推動國家主導的新自由主義式資本主義,以取得領導權及正當性,這也是香港政治發展的所謂「缺失」的歷史。本文要進一步指出,項的香港論述源於他的當代中國敘事,這一套敘事迴避黨國權力在歷史上的重整,以及其實質的政經運作,相反,卻一頭栽進一種黨領導權的神話。項文作為一個例子,說明各種近年興起的中共黨國理論與神話,阻礙了中港兩地,甚至整個華人地區之間的政治及知性對話。
Abstract
Professor Xiang Biao’s commentary on Hong Kong’s “Umbrella
Movement” is a rare attempt among academics in mainland China to discuss
Hong Kong. However, in his discourse, the role of the Chinese Communist
Party in Hong Kong’s democratization is almost invisible and the historical
process by which Hong Kong and China’s political developments have
increasingly diverged is not discussed. This process began in 1989 when the
communist regime violently repressed the demands and agenda for democratic
reform and continued in the 1990s as the state pushed forward neoliberalism in
order to obtain leadership and legitimacy. It is also the history of the
“incompleteness” of Hong Kong’s political development. This article further
points out that Xiang’s narrative of contemporary China from which his
discourse on Hong Kong is derived evades the history of the party-state power
reshuffles and its politico-economic operation in reality. In contrast, it embraces
the myth of party-state leadership. Xiang’s article serves as an example of
various theories and myths of the Chinese Communist Party-state. They pose
obstacles to political and intellectual dialogues between China and Hong Kong,
and also among different Chinese societies.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 研究論文
- 期刊
- 國立臺灣大學考古人類學刊
- ISSN
- 0077-5843
- 卷期
- 83期
- 出版
- 2015年12月
- 頁碼
- 57–74
- 編號
- NTUEJ00004210
同期目錄
- 「社會運動中的人類學介入:香港佔中」專號導言趙彥寧(Antonia Chao)・頁 1–4
- 直面香港:群眾運動中的民主訴求與政黨政治項飈(Xiang Biao)・頁 5–24
- 撐起雨傘的非常城市:遇見他者的閾限空間黃舒楣(Shu-mei Huang);伊恩( Ian Rowen)・頁 25–56
- 直面黨國權力:回應項的「雨傘運動」論述葉蔭聰(Iam-chong Ip)・頁 57–74
- 「群眾」和「黨」:中國革命話語進入佔領運動論述陳浩乾(Haoqian Chen)・頁 75–88
- 回應與反響--我們如何敘述當下、進入歷史:兼論人類學的現實角色項飈(Xiang Biao)・頁 89–102
- 《日常生活中的當代宗教:宗教的個人化與關係性存有》特約書評專欄林瑋嬪(Wei-ping Lin)・頁 103–104
- 《日常生活中的當代宗教:宗教的個人化與關係性存有》書評導言蔡英俊(Ying-chun Tsai)・頁 105–108
- 《日常生活中的當代宗教:宗教的個人化與關係性存有》書評蔡彥仁(Yen-zen Tsai)・頁 109–114
- 《日常生活中的當代宗教:宗教的個人化與關係性存有》書評蔡怡佳(Yi-jia Tsai)・頁 115–122
- 回應與反響黃應貴(Ying-kuei Huang)・頁 123–128