引領學術研究:臺灣TSSCI期刊發表之學術倫理相關規範初探
Leading Academic Research: A Preliminary Study of Taiwan Social Sciences Citation Index–Listed Journals’ Policies Regarding Academic Ethics
國立陽明交通大學教育研究所(Institute of Education, National Yang Ming Chiao Tung University, Hsinchu, Taiwan);國立陽明交通大學人文與社會科學研究中心(Research Center for Humanities and Social Sciences, National Yang Ming Chiao Tung University, Hsinchu, Taiwan);國立公共資訊圖書館(National Library of Public Information, Taichung, Taiwan)
摘要
本研究以臺灣社會科學核心期刊(Taiwan Social Sciences Citation Index, TSSCI)於2018至2019年收錄之110本期刊為研究標的,採用文件分析法,就期刊規範中有關學術倫理、著作權相關要求與規範進行分析討論。研究結果顯示,在110本期刊中,多數強調投稿著作之原創性;約四成清楚表明作者要善盡引用資料之責,不可抄襲或剽竊;另有約三成特別載明論文作者的義務與責任,超過四成則是對共同作者有相關規範;不到三成有明文要求揭露經費來源與利益衝突。依據研究結果,本文提出學術期刊出版之實務建議,包含提供完整充足規範並適時修正;檢視出版倫理與編輯實務去修正規範以處理違反學術倫理案件;參考與接軌國際,強化經營管理之效;面對各式開放理念與出版新趨勢,及早因應研擬規範。
Abstract
This study aims to explore the publishing policies and submission guidelines of 110 academic journals covered in the Taiwan Social Sciences Citation Index (TSSCI) during 2018 and 2019. Using document analysis, information regarding academic ethics and copyright are analyzed. The results indicate that most of the journals emphasize manuscript originality, and some journals have instructions or guidelines for prior publications in conferences, theses and dissertations. In addition, about 40% of journals clearly indicates that authors are obliged to avoid plagiarism and provide proper and accurate citation. Less than 30% of journals specifically state the obligations and responsibilities of scholarly authors and the duties of editors and reviewers. More than 40% of journals set up regulations for co-authorship. Less than 30% of journals clearly state that authors need to make a conflict-of-interest disclosure. Still a few journals use vague or imprecise legal terms in their policies. Based on the results, this study further provides practical advice in academic publishing. Specific suggestions include providing complete submission instructions and revising them in a timely manner, reviewing journal publishing ethics and operating policy to keep in line with international practices, and formulating regulations in response to the various scholarship and journal publishing movements.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 圖書資訊學刊
- ISSN
- 1606-7509
- 卷期
- 20卷2期
- 出版
- 2022年12月
- 頁碼
- 095–127
- 編號
- NTUEJ00004513
同期目錄
- 數位人文研究平臺支援探究式學習促進學生的歷史調查成效陳志銘(Chih-Ming Chen);張鐘(Chung Chang);陳勁佑 (Chin-Yu Chen)・頁 001–028
- 國立臺灣大學社會科學及人文科學領域之出版品多樣性程度趨勢比較張郁蔚(Yu-Wei Chang);蘇鈺淳(Yu-Chun Su)・頁 029–054
- 泰國原生種稻米知識本體論的發展Chokthumrong Chongchorhor, Malee Kabmala・頁 055–074
- 引用影響力研究中以百分等級正規化之缺點Paul Donner・頁 075–093
- 引領學術研究:臺灣TSSCI期刊發表之學術倫理相關規範初探周倩(Chien Chou);潘璿安(Sophia Jui-An Pan);呂瑞蓮(Jui-Lien Lu)・頁 095–127
- 無障礙閱讀資源整合查詢系統介面易用性評估林巧敏(Chiao-Min Lin)・頁 129–160
- 臺灣公共圖書館政策發展:圖書館實務者與專家學者之觀點宋慧筠(Hui-Yun Sung);蔡天怡(Tien-I Tsai)・頁 161–190
- 中國國家圖書館藏宋刻殘本《門類增廣十注杜工部詩》版本考論張其秀(Qi-Xiu Zhang);孫微(Wei Sun)・頁 191–218