美國國家科學基金會研究違失案件之分類與處置:1989─2019年
Analyses of US National Science Foundation’s Suspected Incidents of Noncompliance in Research: 1989-2019
國立陽明交通大學教育研究所(Institute of Education, National Yang Ming Chiao Tung University, Hsinchu, Taiwan);國立陽明交通大學人文與社會科學研究中心(Research Center for Humanities and Social Sciences, National Yang Ming Chiao Tung University, Hsinchu, Taiwan)
摘要
本研究以美國國家科學基金會所建置之「結案備忘錄資料庫」為研究工具,檢索1989年至2019年間共3,064起疑似研究違失案件;分析項目包含案件所涉之行為類型與採取的後續行動,以及兩者在過去31年間之消長。主要結果包括:歷年之疑似研究違失案件共分31種行為類型與五種後續行動;結案總案件數在2004年後顯著增加,並於同年達到高峰;結案案件中以逐字抄襲為最大宗;在後續行動上,情節較輕的案件多是向當事人進行警告,情節較嚴重的案件則最常被施予行政處分,其次則是追回經費與被判定為不當研究行為。本文依研究結果,針對中央主管機關在適度公開案件資訊及建置案件資料庫等面向,提出相關建議與作法。
Abstract
The present study concerned the database, Case Closeout Memoranda, established by the National Science Foundation (NSF) of the United States. In the study, the current authors retrieved 3,064 reported cases of suspected noncompliance in research between 1989 to 2019. We then analyzed the classification of misbehaviors and subsequent actions; the authors also investigated the evolution of the violations and actions over the three decades. The preliminary results include the following: the closed cases over the years can be categorized into 31 types of misbehaviors and 5 types of subsequent actions; the total number of closed cases increased significantly after 2004 and reached a peak in the same year; among the closed cases, verbatim plagiarism accounts for the most significant reported breach, followed by grant frauds; in terms of subsequent actions, individuals with fewer breaches were often warned about questionable research practices, and a major portion of those with more severe issues performed administrative actions, followed by monetary recovery and being defined as research misconduct. Finally, the authors proposed establishing a national case database of noncompliance in research in Taiwan to promote retrospective studies and categorization research further. In addition, the authors hoped that Taiwanese local government ministries and research institutions can consider the suggestions in the article to uphold accountability, transparency, and social responsibility.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 圖書資訊學刊
- ISSN
- 1606-7509
- 卷期
- 20卷1期
- 出版
- 2022年06月
- 頁碼
- 069–099
- 編號
- NTUEJ00004520
同期目錄
- 集成式人工神經網絡模型於分類實務之可行性:以社群媒體之健康消費者資訊分類為例Sukjin You;Min Sook Park, Soohyung Joo・頁 001–030
- 動態資訊圖像對小學中年級資源班與普通班之學習影響蔡仕廷(Shih-Ting Tsai);黃馨儀(Hsin-Yi Huang);張登文(Teng-Wen Chang)・頁 031–048
- 藥品發展事件的公告對藥廠市場價值之影響?以輝瑞公司為例曹喻涵(Yu-Han Tsao);王俊傑(Chun-Chieh Wang)・頁 049–067
- 美國國家科學基金會研究違失案件之分類與處置:1989─2019年周倩(Chien Chou);潘璿安(Sophia Jui-An Pan)・頁 069–099
- 科學特藏文獻之引用與學術貢獻:以田中長三郎對Penzig文庫的引用為例林維真(Weijane Lin);張翔柔(Hsiang-Jou Chang)・頁 101–129
- 政府機關推行開放資料之影響因素探討:量化研究與多群組比較分析楊東謀(Tung-Mou Yang);吳孟家(Meng-Chia Wu)・頁 131–171
- 以社區功能導向探討使用者對於公共圖書館實體空間之關注與期望劉醇郁(Chun-Yu Liu);蘇小鳳(Shiao-Feng Su)・頁 173–202