術寫作之新倫理議題「自我抄襲」:內涵演進、真實案例、現行規範與預防之道
Self-plagiarism in Academic Writing: Concepts, Cases, Regulations, and Best Practices
國立交通大學教育研究所(Institute of Education, National Chiao Tung University, Hsinchu, Taiwan); 國立交通大學人文與社會科學研究中心(Research Center for Humanities and Social Sciences, National Chiao Tung University, Hsinchu, Taiwan)
摘要
近年學術倫理在臺灣受到高度的重視,但由於對自我抄襲的理解與討論有限,故在其認定原則與標準上,尚缺乏明確的共識。有鑑於此,本文之目的在於釐清自我抄襲的內涵,以協助學術界能由更正向與多元的角度看待這個新倫理議題。本文以文本分析法,研析過去與自我抄襲相關的文獻與規範。在論述上,本文首先探討自我抄襲的內涵,包含此概念的演進歷程、定義、判定方式、納入與排除的具體情事,以及應避免為之的原因;接續透過發生於荷蘭的真實案例,敘說自我抄襲所引起的兩極化爭議;本文亦整理出臺灣中央主管機關在自我抄襲相關規範上之沿革,並於文末提出有助於預防自我抄襲的辦法。
Abstract
In recent years, academic ethics has garnered increased attention in Taiwan. However, due to limited understanding and discussion of self-plagiarism, no clear consensus exists on principles and standards for recognizing and handling the issue. The purpose of this study is to clarify key concepts, regulations, and best practices regarding self-plagiarism so that local scholars can approach this new ethical issue from an informed perspective. Using the method of document analysis, published articles are analyzed to illustrate current norms related to self-plagiarism. This article examines the concept of self-plagiarism in terms of the emergence of concern for this ethical issue, relevant definitions, methods for recognizing its occurrence, common types and exclusions, and the importance of avoiding the pitfalls of self-plagiarism. The analysis also cites an actual case of self-plagiarism that took place in the Netherlands to illustrate the controversies surrounding self-plagiarism. In addition, the article summarizes the historical evolution of relevant norms of self-plagiarism in Taiwan and proposes methods to guide best practices regarding ethical academic writing.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 圖書資訊學刊
- ISSN
- 1606-7509
- 卷期
- 18卷2期
- 出版
- 2020年12月
- 頁碼
- 043–072
- 編號
- NTUEJ00004540
同期目錄
- 分享選擇、組織、關聯與調整之結構化閱讀筆記對於學習者的閱讀理解及閱讀焦慮影響陳志銘(Chih-Ming Chen);簡璐嘉(Lu-Chia Chien)・頁 001–029
- 交互作用熵:量化雙層網絡交互作用的新測度張家榕(Ronda J. Zhang);葉鷹(Fred Y. Ye)・頁 031–041
- 術寫作之新倫理議題「自我抄襲」:內涵演進、真實案例、現行規範與預防之道周倩(Chien Chou);潘璿安(Sophia Jui-An Pan)・頁 043–072
- 基於檢索方法的中文幽默對話系統之建置應用與評估曾元顯(Yuen-Hsien Tseng);許瑋倫(Wei-Lun Hsu);吳玟萱(Wun-Syuan Wu);古怡巧(Yi-Ciao Gu);陳學志(Hsueh-Chih Chen)・頁 073–101
- 學者研究資料管理認知與實踐之研究陸怡靖(Yi-Ching Lu);柯皓仁(Hao-Ren Ke)・頁 103–137
- 懷孕婦女知多少?初次懷孕婦女之營養詞彙理解研究初探張家翎(Chia-Ling Chang);邱銘心(Ming-Hsin Phoebe Chiu)・頁 139–165
- 國立北平圖書館排印中文卡片目錄研究雷強(Qiang Lei)・頁 167–201