何謂作者?試以「述而不作」的孔子為例進行分析
What is an Author? Taking Confucius for an Example
行政院原子能委員會核能研究所圖書館(Institute of Nuclear Energy Research Library, Atomic Energy Council, Executive Yuan, Taoyuan City, Taiwan)
摘要
自人類知識文明發展以來,對於「作者」的討論便從未間斷,其在知識組織領域中更被視為一個重要的詮釋資料元素,具有辨識和聚集的功能。本研究以孔子為個案,《史記‧孔子世家》為主要分析文本來源,透過內容分析方法討論:(1)孔子所扮演的作者角色為何?(2)孔子作為作者,有哪些與其相關的書目實體?(3)融合中西方的作者觀分析孔子所展現的作者功能為何?為了解答這些問題,本研究採取三階段分析策略:
一、 在文本中識別出可能的作者角色;
二、 標記出個別書目實體;
三、 解析作者與其他實體間的關係。
經過初步的彙整與分析,本研究發現在《史記‧孔子世家》中所揭露之孔子的作者角色可概分「創作者」、「編輯者」和「傳述者」等三種,進而分別闡述其內涵並解釋其中所涉及的書目實體和書目實體之間的關係,最後討論如何發揮其在書目中的功能。
Abstract
The proposed study is a case study of the author function by examining a famed “author” - Confucius. Preliminary results are presented of an analysis based on “The Hereditary House of Confucius” in The Records of the Grand Historian by Sima Qian that paints a picture of Confucius as an author, as conceived in the 2nd century BCE (the Former Han dynasty). The study uses the method of qualitative content analysis to answer the following research questions: (1) What types of authorship is Confucius said to have performed according to his biography by Sima Qian? (2) What are the works related to Confucius? (3) What does each type of authorship entail? To answer these questions, a three-stage process is conducted to analyze the text: First, isolation of useful segments; then, identification and coding of relevant works mentioned in the biography; and finally, specification and analysis of the outcomes. Tentatively, the analysis has identified at least three types of authorship: writer, editor, and transmitter. As part of a larger study to examine the images of Confucius as an author over time, the primary purpose of the research reported here is to gain more understanding of the author function in Chinese culture. This study’s findings are undoubtedly important for expanding research on authorship in KO. Eventually such research will lead to improved KO system design, especially in the area of author data.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 圖書資訊學刊
- ISSN
- 1606-7509
- 卷期
- 13卷2期
- 出版
- 2015年12月
- 頁碼
- 227–250
- 編號
- NTUEJ00004605
同期目錄
- 從知識建構探索研究生之資訊使用行為周志文(Chih-Wen Jayden Chou);羅思嘉(Szu-Chia Scarlett Lo)・頁 1–27
- 明代江西地方官府藏書事業研究─以各級儒學為考察中心陳冠至(Kuan-Chih Chen)・頁 29–66
- 中高齡者使用公共運輸系統自動售票機之可使用性評估研究: 以大眾捷運系統為例呂明心(Ming-Hsin Lu);岳修平(Hsiu-Ping Yueh)・頁 67–97
- 原住民族、孔子及知識組織:專題編者序李鶴立(Hur-Li Lee)・頁 99–105
- 加拿大Xwi7xwa圖書館之知識組織在地化Ann M. Doyle;Kimberley Lawson;Sarah Dupont・頁 107–134
- 從臺灣原住民族出版相關文獻探討臺灣原住民族知識分布盧谷砳樂(Gu-Le-Le Lu);吳美美(Mei-Mei Wu)・頁 135–160
- 中國藝術領域的中英控制詞彙語意對應陳淑君(Shu-Jiun Chen);陳雪華(Hsueh-Hua Chen)・頁 161–208
- 《論語》作者探究:來自傅柯觀點的啟發劉瑄儀(Hsuan-I Liu)・頁 209–226
- 何謂作者?試以「述而不作」的孔子為例進行分析劉 杰(Chieh Liu)・頁 227–250