書目資料準確性評估自動化之測試研究
Testing an Automated Accuracy Assessment Method on Bibliographic Data
德國柏林洪堡大學圖書館與資訊科學學院(Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin, Berlin School of Library and Information Science, Berlin, Germany)
摘要
本研究探討資料品質文獻所提及的自動化資料準確性評估法,以瞭解其用於評估書目資料時的適切性。本研究用來測試的書目資料為兩位諾貝爾化學獎得主10年內之出版品,書目資料檢索自Web of Science與Scopus;在準確性評估上,分別以自動化與人工兩種評估法進行書目資料準確性測試,之後再跟原始出版品比對,以瞭解人工與自動化評估的高下。研究結果顯示,人工評估法的準確性得分較高,自動化評估法還需要納入更多能反映書目資料特質的評估規則,始能提高準確性。在兩組書目資料的測試中,單一分欄資料準確性的評估,都比整體書目記錄評估的表現要好。本研究之貢獻在於增進對書目資料準確度標準評估法的探討,並說明了資料準確性在引文比對過程中的重大影響。
Abstract
This study investigates automated data accuracy assessment as described in data quality literature for its suitability to assess bibliographic data. The data samples comprise the publications of two Nobel Prize winners in the field of Chemistry for a 10-year-publication period retrieved from the two bibliometric data sources, Web of Science and Scopus. The bibliographic records are assessed against the original publication (gold standard) and an automatic assessment method is compared to a manual one. The results show that the manual assessment method reflects truer accuracy scores. The automated assessment method would need to be extended by additional rules that reflect specific characteristics of bibliographic data. Both data sources had higher accuracy scores per field than accumulated per record. This study contributes to the research on finding a standardized assessment method of bibliographic data accuracy as well as defining the impact of data accuracy on the citation matching process.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 圖書資訊學刊
- ISSN
- 1606-7509
- 卷期
- 12卷2期
- 出版
- 2014年12月
- 頁碼
- 019–038
- 編號
- NTUEJ00004613
同期目錄
- 發明作者與未參與專利活動學術同儕研究生產力與學術影響之比較研究羅思嘉(Szu-chia Scarlett Lo)・頁 001–018
- 書目資料準確性評估自動化之測試研究Marlies Olensky・頁 019–038
- 愛情小說之情緒療癒效用研究─ 以遭遇感情困擾的大學生為例陳書梅 (Chen Su-may Sheih)・頁 039–079
- 探索人文社會學者研究產出之總合軌跡:以臺灣大學人文社會高等研究院為例陳光華(Kuang-Hua Chen);陳雅琦(Ya-Chi Chen)・頁 081–116
- 網路學術資訊尋獲與再尋獲之檢索行為探析卜小蝶(Hsiao-Tieh Pu);江信昱(Xin-Yu Jiang)・頁 117–160
- 《書目答問》史部「國語類」補證:以現行三種匯補著作爲主郭萬青 (Wan-Qing Guo)・頁 161–179