無中文篇名
A Comparison of Three Major Academic Rankings for World Universities: From a Research Evaluation Perspective
國立臺灣大學圖書資訊學系(Department of Library and Information Science, National Taiwan University)
摘要
This paper introduces three current major university ranking systems. The Performance Ranking of Scientific Papers for World Universities by Higher Education Evaluation and Accreditation Council of Taiwan (HEEACT Ranking) emphasizes both the quality and quantity of research and current research performance. The Academic Ranking of World Universities by Shanghai Jiao Tung University (ARWU) focuses on outstanding performance of universities with indicators such as Nobel Prize winners. The QS World University Ranking (2004-2009) by Times Higher Education (THE-QS) emphasizes on peer review with high weighting in evaluation. This paper compares the 2009 ranking results from the three ranking systems. Differences exist in the top 20 universities in three ranking systems except the Harvard University, which scored top one in all of the three rankings. Comparisons also revealed that the THE-QS favored UK universities. Further, obvious differences can be observed between THE-QS and the other two rankings when ranking results of some European countries (Germany, UK, Netherlands, & Switzerland) and Chinese speaking regions were compared.
Abstract
This paper introduces three current major university ranking systems. The Performance Ranking of Scientific Papers for World Universities by Higher Education Evaluation and Accreditation Council of Taiwan (HEEACT Ranking) emphasizes both the quality and quantity of research and current research performance. The Academic Ranking of World Universities by Shanghai Jiao Tung University (ARWU) focuses on outstanding performance of universities with indicators such as Nobel Prize winners. The QS World University Ranking (2004-2009) by Times Higher Education (THE-QS) emphasizes on peer review with high weighting in evaluation. This paper compares the 2009 ranking results from the three ranking systems. Differences exist in the top 20 universities in three ranking systems except the Harvard University, which scored top one in all of the three rankings. Comparisons also revealed that the THE-QS favored UK universities. Further, obvious differences can be observed between THE-QS and the other two rankings when ranking results of some European countries (Germany, UK, Netherlands, & Switzerland) and Chinese speaking regions were compared.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 圖書資訊學刊
- ISSN
- 1606-7509
- 卷期
- 9卷1期
- 出版
- 2011年06月
- 頁碼
- 001–025
- 編號
- NTUEJ00004654
同期目錄
- 無中文篇名黃慕萱(Mu-hsuan Huang)・頁 001–025
- 無中文篇名Sei-Ching Joanna Sin・頁 027–049
- 無中文篇名Xiaohua Zhu・頁 051–076
- 大學圖書館讀者負面情緒類型與成因之質化研究陳書梅(Chen Su-may Sheih)・頁 077–121
- 學生對服務學習數位影音資源之使用經驗與知覺助益研究岳修平(Hsiu-Ping Yueh);邱立安(Li-An Chiu)・頁 123–160
- 虛擬社群的資訊分享行為蔡至欣(Chih-Hsin Tsai);賴玲玲(Ling-Ling Lai)・頁 161–196