無中文篇名
The National Site Licensing of Electronic Resources: An Institutional Perspective
美國威斯康辛大學麥迪遜校區圖書館與資訊研究系 (School of Library and Information Studies, University of Wisconsin - Madison)
摘要
While academic libraries in most countries are struggling to negotiate with publishers and vendors individually or collaboratively via consortia, a few countries have experimented with a different model, national site licensing (NSL). Because NSL often involves government and large-scale collaboration, it has the potential to solve many problems in the complex licensing world. However, not many nations have adopted it. This study uses historical research approach and the comparative case study research method to explore the seemingly low level of adoption. The cases include the Canadian National Site Licensing Project (CNSLP), the United Kingdom’s National Electronic Site Licensing Initiative (NESLI), and the United States, which has not adopted NSL. The theoretical framework guiding the research design and data collection is W. Richard Scott’s institutional theory, which utilizes three supporting pillars—regulative, normative, and cultural-cognitive—to analyze institutional processes. In this study, the regulative pillar and the normative pillar of NSL adoption—an institutional construction and change—are examined. Data were collected from monographs, research articles, government documents, and relevant websites. Based on the analysis of these cases, a preliminary model is proposed for the adoption of NSL. The factors that support a country’s adoption of NSL include the need for new institutions, a centralized educational policy-making system and funding system, supportive political trends, and the tradition of cooperation. The factors that may prevent a country from adopting NSL include decentralized educational policy and funding, diversity and the large number of institutions, the concern for the “Big Deal,” and the concern for monopoly.
Abstract
While academic libraries in most countries are struggling to negotiate with publishers and vendors individually or collaboratively via consortia, a few countries have experimented with a different model, national site licensing (NSL). Because NSL often involves government and large-scale collaboration, it has the potential to solve many problems in the complex licensing world. However, not many nations have adopted it. This study uses historical research approach and the comparative case study research method to explore the seemingly low level of adoption. The cases include the Canadian National Site Licensing Project (CNSLP), the United Kingdom’s National Electronic Site Licensing Initiative (NESLI), and the United States, which has not adopted NSL. The theoretical framework guiding the research design and data collection is W. Richard Scott’s institutional theory, which utilizes three supporting pillars—regulative, normative, and cultural-cognitive—to analyze institutional processes. In this study, the regulative pillar and the normative pillar of NSL adoption—an institutional construction and change—are examined. Data were collected from monographs, research articles, government documents, and relevant websites. Based on the analysis of these cases, a preliminary model is proposed for the adoption of NSL. The factors that support a country’s adoption of NSL include the need for new institutions, a centralized educational policy-making system and funding system, supportive political trends, and the tradition of cooperation. The factors that may prevent a country from adopting NSL include decentralized educational policy and funding, diversity and the large number of institutions, the concern for the “Big Deal,” and the concern for monopoly.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 圖書資訊學刊
- ISSN
- 1606-7509
- 卷期
- 9卷1期
- 出版
- 2011年06月
- 頁碼
- 051–076
- 編號
- NTUEJ00004656
同期目錄
- 無中文篇名黃慕萱(Mu-hsuan Huang)・頁 001–025
- 無中文篇名Sei-Ching Joanna Sin・頁 027–049
- 無中文篇名Xiaohua Zhu・頁 051–076
- 大學圖書館讀者負面情緒類型與成因之質化研究陳書梅(Chen Su-may Sheih)・頁 077–121
- 學生對服務學習數位影音資源之使用經驗與知覺助益研究岳修平(Hsiu-Ping Yueh);邱立安(Li-An Chiu)・頁 123–160
- 虛擬社群的資訊分享行為蔡至欣(Chih-Hsin Tsai);賴玲玲(Ling-Ling Lai)・頁 161–196