A Comparative Analysis of the Application of H-index, G-index, and A-index in Institutional-Level Research Evaluation
Department of Library and Information Science, National Taiwan University;Institute for Research Information and Quality Assurance, Germany
Abstract
This study compared the application of h-index, g-index, and A-index in institutional level research evaluation. 99 universities in Taiwan were ranked by the three indices. Most of the universities had relatively low publication and citation numbers at the time of this study. The analysis focused on the range of equal values resulted from the three different indices, the range of disparity, the order or rank, and the degree of correlation among the indices. The results showed that g-index and h-index were similar in that the use of the two indices produced similar values and rankings. Both had the problem of equal value in which multiple universities got the same index value, making it difficult to differentiate the universities’ performance. In contrast, A-index was able to rank the universities by
emphasizing on the highly cited articles and at the same time avoided the problem of equal value. It was thus considered a better index for the institutional level research evaluation in Taiwan.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 圖書資訊學刊
- ISSN
- 1606-7509
- 卷期
- 8卷2期
- 出版
- 2010年12月
- 頁碼
- 001–010
- 編號
- NTUEJ00004660
同期目錄
- A Comparative Analysis of the Application of H-index, G-index, and A-index in Institutional-Level Research EvaluationMu-hsuan Huang;Pei-shan Chi・頁 001–010
- Competition and Excellence: Ranking of World-class Universities 2009 and Advance of Chinese UniversitiesJun-ping Qiu;Ruixian Yang;Rongying Zhao・頁 011–027
- 數位時代的閱讀:青少年網路閱讀的爭議與未來林珊如(Shan-Ju Lin Chang)・頁 029–053
- 臺灣與日本雙邊科學合作之探討:2000-2009年合著論文之書目計量研究張郁蔚(Yu-Wei Chang)・頁 055–093
- 鄧雨賢數位典藏加值應用研究—以文化產品設計為例莊育振(Yu-Cheng Chuang);楊東翰(Don-Han Yung)・頁 095–123
- 跨領域學術社群之智識網絡結構初探:以臺灣科技與社會研究為例袁大鈺(Da-Yu Yuan);唐牧群(Muh-Chyun Tang)・頁 125–163