Decoupling Trade and Cybersecurity: A Way to Recalibration?
Lecturer at School of Law, Guangdong University of Foreign Studies (GDUFS).
摘要
This article aims at providing an alternative explanation to cybersecurity conundrum in trade. This article takes a systemic and holistic stance to observe cybersecurity by applying an institutionalist approach to analyze the cybersecurity provisions in free trade agreements (hereinafter “FTAs”) and the norm-making processes on cybersecurity under the auspice of the United Nations (hereinafter “UN”). The observations indicate that the cybersecurity provisions in FTAs may serve as implicit diversions from the trade commitments, while the norm-making processes on cybersecurity under the UN produce a minimum public order. This represents a shared understanding of states that international law falls short in the context of cybersecurity, although it is necessary to give greater attention. As the shared understanding may incentivize interactions between decision-making processes, the trade rules may further have less constraint on state behavior in the context of cybersecurity. In this regard, cybersecurity “decouples” from trade disciplines, which enables the states to recalibrate the multilateral trading system. Furthermore, this article considers that the “decoupling” arises from receiving and reconstructing the mercantilist practices pertaining to cybersecurity. Finally, this article considers that institutional linkages would be a way to recouple trade and cybersecurity, although there would still be a long march.
Abstract
This article aims at providing an alternative explanation to cybersecurity conundrum in trade. This article takes a systemic and holistic stance to observe cybersecurity by applying an institutionalist approach to analyze the cybersecurity provisions in free trade agreements (hereinafter “FTAs”) and the norm-making processes on cybersecurity under the auspice of the United Nations (hereinafter “UN”). The observations indicate that the cybersecurity provisions in FTAs may serve as implicit diversions from the trade commitments, while the norm-making processes on cybersecurity under the UN produce a minimum public order. This represents a shared understanding of states that international law falls short in the context of cybersecurity, although it is necessary to give greater attention. As the shared understanding may incentivize interactions between decision-making processes, the trade rules may further have less constraint on state behavior in the context of cybersecurity. In this regard, cybersecurity “decouples” from trade disciplines, which enables the states to recalibrate the multilateral trading system. Furthermore, this article considers that the “decoupling” arises from receiving and reconstructing the mercantilist practices pertaining to cybersecurity. Finally, this article considers that institutional linkages would be a way to recouple trade and cybersecurity, although there would still be a long march.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- Asian Journal of WTO & International Health Law and policy
- ISSN
- 1819-5164
- 卷期
- 18卷1期
- 出版
- 2023年03月
- 頁碼
- 39–88
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000047
同期目錄
- Determinants of Antidumping Policy: Interests, Interactions, and InstitutionsYan Cai, Yu Gao, Dongxu Yang & Eunmi Kim・頁 1–38
- Decoupling Trade and Cybersecurity: A Way to Recalibration?Xin Wang・頁 39–88
- A Parallel Narrative: Pluralistic Reconciliation Through Quantizing Geoeconomics in (Cyber)security Governance in International Economic LawXinyue Li・頁 89–130
- Compulsory Licenses for Pharmaceutical Patents in China in Light of the TRIPS AgreementQian YIN・頁 131–180
- Between Old and New: Rethinking Modernization of China’s IIA RegimeKeer Huang・頁 181–230
- The Revival of Spectre: Voluntary Import Expansions and the WTO CompatibilityYaoyuan Zhang・頁 231–276