921地震對原住民土地權益與地方認同重構的衝擊
The Impacts of the September 21st Earthquake on Indigenous Peoples’ Land Rights and the Reconstruction of Place Identity in Taiwan
國立東華大學民族發展所(Graduate Institute of the Development for Indigenous Peoples, National Dong-Hwa University)
- 卷期
- 31期
- 出版
- 2002年06月
- 頁碼
- 001–015
- 編號
- NTUEJ00005043
Abstract
Many of Taiwan’s indigenous peoples’ struggles on land rights are related to the maintenance of ethnic cultural traditions, local resource management, and the establishment of place identity and sense of place. The earthquake of September 21st, 1999, has provided an opportunity to re-examine (1) the land rights issues among the Han people, the state, and the indigenous people and (2) the relationship between tribal and communal reconstruction and place identity. Indigenous land rights struggles have accelerated since the establishment of the “Plains Peoples’ Rights Association”(PPRA) in 1993 in Ho-Ping Hsian, Taichung County. The PPRA demands that indigenous reservation land policy be abolished and that all reservation land be open to market forces and free trade. The illegal land transfers from indigenous people to Han people have been a politically thorny question concerning Taiwan’s mountain development policy since the intrusion of market forces in the mid-1960s. Moreover, the devastating earthquake could force some tribes in Ho-Ping to relocate their whole population to new areas where their land rights are even less secure. How the PPRA and the indigenous people will respond to this new situation and the impact of the earthquake on land rights conflicts
are the questions explored in this research. Furthermore, in addition to the indigenous land rights issues, place identity and sense of place of tribes people are also closely related to the land. The rebuilding of tribes and communities after the earthquake, which coincided with successive waves
of the PPRA’s call for the “liberation” of reservation land, provides an opportunity to investigate critically the potential changes in place identity and sense of place among local residents. The paper employs various theories of identity, each anchored in the broad field of New Cultural Geography. Theories of political economy are also applied to analyze land conflicts between two ethnic groups, with emphasis on the spatial dimension. This paper aims to reveal the geographical, economic, social, and political marginalization of Taiwan’s indigenous peoples and provides a theoretical base for future research on land-related topics.