《書目答問》與《四庫全書總目》別史類分類之比較
A Comparative Study of Historical Classification of Bie-shi in Shu-mu Da-wen and Si-ku Quan-shu Zong-mu
國立臺灣大學歷史學系(Department of History, National Taiwan University)
摘要
「別史」是史部類例中較晚出現的,在史部的地位亦相當模糊。雖然可以「上不至於正史,下不至於離史」概括說明,卻不易清楚界定其範圍。歷來書目設有別史類者,更是屈指可數。《書目答問》與《四庫全書總目》是近代兩部重要的書目,其史部皆有別史一類。本文乃以此二書目為主,比較其別史類所收圖書分類之異同,希望有助於釐清別史之特性。
Abstract
The utilization of Bie-shi (alternative histories) as a class in traditional historical classification began in Sung Dynasty. Bie-shi is usually defined as “a category which is not as formal as Zheng-shi (Official Dynastic Histories), but not as casual as Za-shi (Miscellaneous histories).” Still, the meaning and coverage of Bie-shi is not quite clear and well-established. It was not a common category employed in traditional historical classification schemes either. Shu-mu Da-wen (Answers to Inquiries into Bibliography) and Si-ku Quan-shu Zong-mu (Annotated Catalog of the Si-ku Collection) are two important bibliographies in Qing Dynasty. They both employed Bie-shi as a category to classify related works. This study attempts to compare and analyze the historical works that were classified in Bie-shi category of these two bibliographies. The goal is to provide a clearer picture about the characteristics of Bie-shi.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 大學圖書館
- ISSN
- 1682-2889
- 卷期
- 9卷1期
- 出版
- 2005年03月
- 頁碼
- 143–156
- 編號
- NTUEJ00005234
同期目錄
- 分類不一致對文件自動分類效果之影響曾元顯(Yuen-Hsien Tseng)・頁 002–019
- 以檢索需求分析模式提升圖像檢索應用之研究卜小蝶(Hsiao-Tieh Pu)・頁 020–034
- 大學圖書館即時數位參考咨詢服務使用者隱私權政策初探蘇小鳳(Shiao-Feng Su)・頁 035–048
- 資訊素養教學評量探討于第(Ti Yu)・頁 049–067
- 大學圖書館館員資訊素養之研究林建隆(Jang-Long Lin);孫本初(Ben-Chu Sun);鍾錦雲(Chin-Yun Chung)・頁 068–092
- 臺灣大學所藏活字本《紅樓夢》簡述劉廣定(Kwang-Ting Liu);張寶三(Pao-San Chang);黃郁雯(Yu-Wen Hwang)・頁 093–099
- 數位化計畫中合作之探討洪淑芬(Shu-Feng Hung Lin)・頁 100–122
- 楊氏海源閣及其藏書略述姜民(Ming Chiang)・頁 123–142
- 《書目答問》與《四庫全書總目》別史類分類之比較蔡天怡(Tien-I Tsai)・頁 143–156