Legalized Backsliding: The Product Under Consideration in the WTO Anti-Dumping Agreement
Qingjiang Kong, School of International Law, China University of Political Science and Law; Li Chen, Fudan University Law School.
摘要
The scope of “product under consideration” (hereinafter “PUC”) is the basis for conducting an anti-dumping investigation. However, the World Trade Organization (hereinafter “WTO”) Anti-Dumping Agreement does not provide any explicit details about this definition; the result is that many issues remain in legal limbo. This study aims to reveal the legal and politico-economic problems arising from the ambiguity of the PUC definition, suggesting alternatives for its amendment. To this end, we conduct analyses of the cases of EC — Fasteners and EU — Footwear. Our legal analyses reveal that both the “internal likeness” claim and the “cross-likeness” claim would be rejected by the Panel. Our politico-economic analyses highlight that the WTO Anti-Dumping Agreement acts as a form of “legalized backsliding” which allows investigating authorities to abuse their broad discretion to satisfy protection-seeking interest parties in determining the scope of PUCs. This study recommends either inserting substantive and procedural provisions to determine PUCs in the Anti-Dumping Agreement as the best option or inserting them in Free Trade Agreements as the second-best option.
Abstract
The scope of “product under consideration” (hereinafter “PUC”) is the basis for conducting an anti-dumping investigation. However, the World Trade Organization (hereinafter “WTO”) Anti-Dumping Agreement does not provide any explicit details about this definition; the result is that many issues remain in legal limbo. This study aims to reveal the legal and politico-economic problems arising from the ambiguity of the PUC definition, suggesting alternatives for its amendment. To this end, we conduct analyses of the cases of EC — Fasteners and EU — Footwear. Our legal analyses reveal that both the “internal likeness” claim and the “cross-likeness” claim would be rejected by the Panel. Our politico-economic analyses highlight that the WTO Anti-Dumping Agreement acts as a form of “legalized backsliding” which allows investigating authorities to abuse their broad discretion to satisfy protection-seeking interest parties in determining the scope of PUCs. This study recommends either inserting substantive and procedural provisions to determine PUCs in the Anti-Dumping Agreement as the best option or inserting them in Free Trade Agreements as the second-best option.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- Asian Journal of WTO & International Health Law and policy
- ISSN
- 1819-5164
- 卷期
- 17卷2期
- 出版
- 2022年09月
- 頁碼
- 371–404
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000054
同期目錄
- Hong Kong’s Participation in International Dispute Settlement: Deviations from Conventional SovereigntyJulien Chaisse & Xueliang Ji・頁 287–330
- Implications of the EU’s Position on Trade Distortion for EU-China Trade Relations: From Selective Adaptation to Coordinated ComplianceChao Wang & Taixia Shen・頁 331–370
- Legalized Backsliding: The Product Under Consideration in the WTO Anti-Dumping AgreementYan Cai, Eunmi Kim, Zhuoqi Teng & Yuantao Fang・頁 371–404
- Rethinking Investment Treaties for Sustainable Development: From the “New Delhi Declaration” Principles to Modern Investment Law & PolicyXu Qian・頁 405–448
- The Presumption of Conformity for Climate Measures: Reconciling the Climate Change Regime and the WTOHyuntaik Lee・頁 449–482
- Modalities of Securing Policy Autonomy in Preferential Trade AgreementsTae Jung Park & Kil Won Lee・頁 483–514
- Adaptation of Lever Effect Theory to the New Context: A Re-Examination of the Relationship Between Agriculture Dispute Settlement and Negotiation in the WTOHui Chen・頁 515–554
- A Book Review on Petros C. Mavroidis “The WTO Dispute Settlement System: How, Why and Where?” (Edward Elgart, 2022)Yueming Yan・頁 555–564